Christian’s Reviews > A Basic Introduction to Biblical Hebrew: with CD > Status Update
Christian
is on page 20 of 296
Brilliant grammar. The only thing I don't like so far is that she intersperses her discussion of vowels as she introduces the consonants. I would prefer her to do a ch or mltp on the vowels after a student has consonants down. Also would make it easier to reference.
— Dec 28, 2024 07:55PM
Like flag
Christian’s Previous Updates
Christian
is on page 148 of 296
Interesting that she doesn't devote a chapter to either the Pual or the hophal. Simply a paragraph in the piel and hiphil ch.
— Jan 26, 2025 07:46PM
Christian
is on page 95 of 296
I like her discussion on the consecutive imperfect. I think it makes more sense to call it a consecutive preterite (as she does) rather than the norm (consecutive imperfect).
— Jan 02, 2025 11:24AM
Christian
is on page 49 of 296
Second critique:
I don't like that she flips the paradigms to match other language grammars. Traditionally, Hebrew grammars list paradigms in this order: 3ms,3fs,2ms ,2fs, etc. but she flips it (1cs, 2ms ,2fs, 3ms, etc.). She's trying to match modern linguistic convention. However there is a reason we use the traditional method, and I think her method is not the best personally for learning biblical Hebrew .
— Dec 30, 2024 06:50PM
I don't like that she flips the paradigms to match other language grammars. Traditionally, Hebrew grammars list paradigms in this order: 3ms,3fs,2ms ,2fs, etc. but she flips it (1cs, 2ms ,2fs, 3ms, etc.). She's trying to match modern linguistic convention. However there is a reason we use the traditional method, and I think her method is not the best personally for learning biblical Hebrew .
Comments Showing 1-3 of 3 (3 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Parker
(new)
Dec 29, 2024 03:50AM
Yeah, that's odd.
reply
|
flag
Right? She's huehjergards wife, so she has a lot of good linguistic insights. And she adds in background info that's helpful. Like how Phoenician lost the shin sound so Hebrew changed the alphabet to retain it.

