Alone chat - SPOILERS!

Something that inevitably comes up when I’m talking to people about my work is my love of using first person. I am an unashamed Firstie. But first person can be a divisive beast. First person present tense? Well… I may as well have just told you I hate kittens and puppies (Of course I don’t – I’m not a monster!).

When asked about my obsession with first person writing, I always answer with some variation of how first person PoV feels incredibly immersive for me, like I’m actually inside the character’s head. I like that, I like those deep thoughts, getting to experience what the character is, though it can be incredibly difficult when the character is having a rough time – I’m looking at you, Sabine in Ask Me Again and also you, Celeste in Alone.

Speaking of Alone, I’ve had a few people approach me as they’ve been reading with their thoughts and theories, so I thought I’d try to explain a few things and what I hoped to accomplish. I've tried all kinds of magic, but it seems I can't use spoiler tags for blog posts. If you haven’t read Alone then keep reading at your own peril. I take no responsibility for spoiled things!


THIS
IS
SPOILER
SPACING
AND
IS
PROBABLY
COMPLETELY
POINTLESS
BUT
I'M
HAVING
FUN
HITTING
THE
ENTER
KEY
:)



Alone was really the perfect vessel for a first person present tense novel. The present tense was natural and immediately comfortable for someone like Celeste who is just living moment to moment by herself. It gives you tedium, it gives you her immediate sense of her experience, it forces you to be involved. Double thumbs up. The first person sticks you right inside the mind of someone living in an interesting scenario. Double thumbs and double toes up.

If you read the blurb, then I think it’s rather obvious that Olivia is part of the whole thing from the start. Even if you don’t, I’m pretty sure it’s clear she’s involved somehow. Some people are picking up on who she is, others just that she’s in on it. Come closer...closer…no, that’s too close, you’re standing on my foot.

I wanted that.

I wanted you, the reader to experience the book and the whole while know something was coming. Know that Olivia wasn’t quite who she said she was. And I wanted you to be stuck inside someone’s head who had NO idea what was going on, until she knew. Because how good is that? Well not good, but you know, good. Honestly, I’m feeling a little bit smug about it. Okay okay, it’s a bit manipulative Clockwork Orange of me to force readers to be rushing towards a train wreck inside an oblivious bystander’s head, but at the same time – I’m not sorry.

But, pals, I admit, it was hard to write. Not in the sense of getting words onto a page but to have someone like Celeste and put her through that. To be in the head of someone who doesn’t know, but I knew everything that was happening. Talk about a head trip.
I’ve also spotted some really interesting things about the deeper psychological nature of the whole thing, which has been awesome to read. You guys are so clever.

One of the trickiest things for me with this book was Olivia’s genuine love for Celeste. Because as Celeste said (and I’m paraphrasing here) ‘If you loved me, how could you do that?’ Fair point. Poor Olivia, she really was wedged firm between rock and hard place. A bigger/longer explanation of Olivia’s reasoning and feelings was something I would have loved to delve into further to really push it home that she did the best she could with the cards she’d been dealt. And yes, it’s a legit deep lurve and connection.
But pace and flow and all that. And being a first person novel, well here you have one of its limitations. So I did the best I could and hoped with everything that people saw that Olivia was genuine, though her method was perhaps not the best it was all she could do when forced by their shared circumstances.

Ugh, I could ramble for hours about this. But I’m at work and supposed to be doing actual job things, but I just had to blurt this out.

Guys, I love this novel. But like I’ve been saying – it’s a bit weird. But good weird…
8 likes ·   •  7 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on June 12, 2019 15:50
Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lex (new)

Lex Kent It's important for me to connect to characters when I'm reading a book. And In my opinion there is no better way to connect than a well written first person story. I could not imagine Ask, Tell being the same without almost feeling the sleep deprivation that Sabine goes through or the big "exciting" scene she has. Not to mention what made Alone so darn good is that you have front row tickets to the journey Celeste was on. That psychic distance is so wonderfully close that you can almost feel what she is going through. I just can't imagine these books being in third person. I don't think they would be half as powerful as they are. My vote is for first:)


message 2: by E.J. (new)

E.J. Noyes Lex wrote: "It's important for me to connect to characters when I'm reading a book. And In my opinion there is no better way to connect than a well written first person story. I could not imagine Ask, Tell bei..."

I can't imagine them any other way either. Sweet, sweet first person :)

The WIP of the moment, Reaping the Benefits is my first foray into third and oh boy does it feel distant. Highly likely I'll convert it to first unless I can figure out my third mojo.


message 3: by Bugs (new)

Bugs Thanks for sharing your insights about your Alone writing rationale and experience, E.J. I have too much to say about Alone that I'm just gonna shut up about it bc... As to the first-person narrative, as I'd mentioned, whilst 1st-person always (imo) gives the reader a more personal rapport with the characters, adding present tense to the entire narrative makes the story and the MC's psyche/state of mind much, much more visceral, which, at least for me, transfers to the reader immersed in the characters, situation and story altogether perfectly, emotionally and psychologically. So, thank you for adding that brilliant ingredient to this incredible story. Oh, Olivia, Olivia, Olivia...! From the very beginning! Even before.....you know what I mean? Oh, I knew who she was. ;) I'm sure you know how I felt about her character...all I can say is, thank you. Becs and now Olivia. Gosh....! You're gonna kill me dead one of these days w/ your un-fckn-forgettable secondary MCs!

It's very interesting that when you're used to writing 1st-person, 3rd person feels distant. You know what, it's the same for me as a reader, too. It's weird that I'm saying this because I never used to entertain 1st-person narratives, I was fiercely protective of the 3rd-person. But after me true 1st experience with a brilliantly written 1st-person story, I felt my whole psyche shifted - for a person who loves to immerse in the characters and the stories emotionally and intellectually, I felt the 1st person effect, especially when it dealt with the mental, psychological and emotional state of the character, the results were so much more visceral, contemplative and acute. The rest is history. Don't get me wrong, I still love 3rd-person but now I'm very aware of the stark difference in how me psyche reacts. Also, these 2 formats don't always work on all stories. Sometimes, it's good to read someone's story as an observer, not a participant, which the 1st-person option usually (for me at least!) compels the reader to be.

So, for your WIP, I'd be curious to see how you tackle a 3rd-person narrative, downright intrigued, even, tbh! ;) But hey, do what makes you feel comfy, eh? Either way, I can't bloody wait to read it! And I don't even know what it's about! Yup, no worries, no doubt, as far as I'm concerned, bc you're one of the few on me list whose work, even if just a mere sheet of paper scribbled with random words or numbers, I'd be devouring it with utter enthusiasm. End of......What. Have. You. Done?!

Out of sheer curiosity, what's Reaping the Benefits about, eh, if you don't mind me askin'? ;)

Anyway, good luck and have fun crafting your art piece! :)


message 4: by E.J. (new)

E.J. Noyes Bugs wrote: "Thanks for sharing your insights about your Alone writing rationale and experience, E.J. I have too much to say about Alone that I'm just gonna shut up about it bc... As to the first-person narrati..."

Well...I'm sure the third person I spit out will be fine, and this book would suit it. But I want more than "fine". We'll see. I might figure out how to make it intimate while in third.

And gasp, Bugs!
Reaping the Benefits is the title of the "Death's Minion" book. Wife came up with the idea. You know, Grim Reaper and all that...she's pretty pleased with herself :D


message 5: by Bugs (new)

Bugs E.J. wrote: "And gasp, Bugs!
Reaping the Benefits is the title of the "Death's Minion" book. Wife came up with the idea. You know, Grim Reaper and all that...she's pretty pleased with herself :D"


OMFG!!! GRIM REAPER?!?! STFU!!!! Are you winding me up?! Hope not coz I’m beside meself with utter excitement and anticipation!!!! Bloody hell!!! How much longer before I get me hands on it, eh? Oh shite! You’re gonna say it’s 2020, aren’t ya? Gaaaaahhhhhh!!!! 😫

And oh,,,, even if you decide to write in 4th person (cue the “Twilight Zone” theme!), I’ll still be fckn loving it!!!! You ROCK, mate!!!! Are we there yet? Are we there yet? Are we there yet? 😃


message 6: by E.J. (new)

E.J. Noyes Bugs wrote:...


Yeah, 2020.
Come on, Bugs - I've already got If the Shoe Fits for later this year :D

4th person...don't tempt me. I'm an ambitious idiot.


message 7: by Bugs (new)

Bugs I know.. :( I'm just greedy! ;D BUT....I'm forever grateful to you for giving us If The Shoe Fits to tide me over this year, which btw, I'm bloody chuffed about!! Can't wait to find out what's in store for one of me all-time fav lesfic couples!!!! :D

LOL!!!! You know I'll be cheering you on, mate! Just give us a shout at any time and I'll be getting me poms-poms at the ready! ;D


back to top