I almost addressed this in the post about House Rules, but changed my mind at the last second. I decided that it was weighty enough to earn a post in its own right. I want to look at the Rogue’s sneak attack in the light of critical hits. In the game I play now, the DM has ruled that when a Rogue makes a critical hit (a natural 20 to hit) when making a Sneak Attack, he/she only gets a single extra die. So, if the Rogue gets a 1d6 from their weapon, and say 5d6 from their Sneak Attack, for a tota...