Listopia > Goodreads Disappointments: Great Rating, not-so-great Read
Books I've noticed / read because of their Goodreads Rating... that turned out less interesting than I had hoped for.
44 books ·
20 voters ·
list created July 17th, 2011
by Stefan Mesch (votes) .
Stefan
4048 books
300 friends
300 friends
Idril Celebrindal
3102 books
8 friends
8 friends
Robert
4255 books
751 friends
751 friends
Bri
531 books
23 friends
23 friends
Allison
7611 books
84 friends
84 friends
Talyah
1865 books
75 friends
75 friends
Aleksandar
64 books
77 friends
77 friends
Matt
359 books
0 friends
0 friends
More voters…
Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jenn
(last edited Sep 11, 2012 03:43AM)
(new)
Sep 11, 2012 03:40AM
Looking for Alaska is a disappointment?! SERIOUSLY? What were you expecting to read from this book? Rainbows and unicorns?! Well, I'd be disappointed too if that's what I expected.
reply
|
flag
Hey Jenn! Nope - I *like* books about loss, complicated relationships, dying etc.. The characters didn't ring true to me, and everyone walked around as if under a fog:I know how many people love John Green (plus: on Youtube, in his videos, he seems like an energetic, fun person). But when I read "Alaska", I expected something honest, intense and devastating. Instead, I had to spend time with a bunch of pretty dull, bland and morose kids. No sparks! :-(
Ah, if that's what you're looking for, you should try his other book "The Fault in our Stars".I didn't expect anything before reading Alaska. That must be why I just enjoyed it a lot. The only thing that made me want to read it (that's an understatement. I really had a great impulse to read it) was the sort of long quote that was all over Tumblr (with hurricane and drizzle thingy).
Whoa - thanks for the comment! I'll give Green another try, then!If you can, get "Please ignore Vera Dietz".
It's not super-sad / extremely deep. But the main character has SUCH an edge, such a fierce tone... I think it's very similar to "Alaska". But the more interesting personality / voice of the narrator made all the difference, for me.








