This list is for the dark, edgy, un-PC, envelope-pushing bodice rippers of the 70s and 80s. "Dark, down 'n' dirty" are guidelines. Themes include slavery, rape, incest, abuse, and other stuff you won't find in today's romances.
PLEASE DO NOT ADD BOOKS TO THIS LIST!! If you'd like to see one added, post a comment with the title (bookcover image works fine) and a reason or two why you think it qualifies. A previous list became filled with Johanna Lindsey and Lisa Kleypas titles, rendering it practically useless. I will update it ASAP.
Suggested reasons (and a high or intense quantity of them is encouraged)
--rape
--gang rape
--multiple abuses by hero (a slap doesn't count)
--slavery & the abuses/degradation that come with it
--incest
--child abuse
--random extreme stuff like castration (Hello, Stormfire!)
--very under-aged heroines
--violence and/or gore
--necrophilia
PLEASE DO NOT ADD BOOKS TO THIS LIST!! If you'd like to see one added, post a comment with the title (bookcover image works fine) and a reason or two why you think it qualifies. A previous list became filled with Johanna Lindsey and Lisa Kleypas titles, rendering it practically useless. I will update it ASAP.
Suggested reasons (and a high or intense quantity of them is encouraged)
--rape
--gang rape
--multiple abuses by hero (a slap doesn't count)
--slavery & the abuses/degradation that come with it
--incest
--child abuse
--random extreme stuff like castration (Hello, Stormfire!)
--very under-aged heroines
--violence and/or gore
--necrophilia
119 books ·
257 voters ·
list created February 15th, 2012
by deleted user.
Sandi *~The Pirate Wench~*
25125 books
89 friends
89 friends
Sharon
260 books
32 friends
32 friends
Sarah Mac
4297 books
72 friends
72 friends
Joli
1079 books
10 friends
10 friends
Stephanie
119587 books
53 friends
53 friends
Wendy, Lady Evelyn Quince
12699 books
286 friends
286 friends
April
3558 books
448 friends
448 friends
Janka
5319 books
47 friends
47 friends
More voters…
Comments Showing 1-50 of 73 (73 new)
I can't remember
as a BR. A suggestion:
I loved that one. Has anyone read it?Edit Revision
Well hell now I see the voting section on the left of the screen. Very cool Karla.
um, can you add The Flame and the Flower, or is it too obvious (or not extreme enough)? It was the book that started it all, after all. It has abduction, rape, a very young heroine with a Hero in his 30s, a crazy ex-mistress, a murder plot, and one of the best original alpha Heroes.
(says Tammy from her crazy Woodiwiss corner)
Dangerous Obsession fits the criteria.It's been a few years since I read this one...I think I sent it to you Karla through BookMooch...anyway, the book begins with the rape of Rawhnie, probably about 15 or 16 yrs. old (underage heroine) and...(I think he carried the rape thru), her Uncle, that is (Incest) All the while the H, Seth? (who is the son of the main characters in Savage Surrender sits in the parlor listening to whole shabang. Just prior to that, Uncle (beat)Rawhnie in front of Seth before dragging her upstairs to rape her for her mouthiness.
Seth witnesses this, takes it all in, then just gets up and leaves. But Rawhnie sneaks away from Uncle and catches up with Seth (who is actually a stranger to her)... Turns out, Seth is one cold blooded, cruel SOB. He makes Rawhnie become his mistress and continues thru the entire story as cruel and rotten to the core.
Definitely should be on the list.
Edit.....Ok, Rawhnie is Rhawnie and she was probably 14 or 15 yrs old
April wrote: "
Tender Fury by Connie Mason"
April, I've added the book, but can you give me a couple reasons why you think it's down & dirty?
Jeanine, same with you. I don't know the qualifications for The Love Slave & Bold Blades Flashing off the top of my head.
Tender Fury by Connie Mason"April, I've added the book, but can you give me a couple reasons why you think it's down & dirty?
Jeanine, same with you. I don't know the qualifications for The Love Slave & Bold Blades Flashing off the top of my head.
Karla (Mossy Love Grotto) wrote: "April wrote: "
Tender Fury by Connie Mason"April, I've added the book, but can you give me a couple reasons why you think it's down & dirty?
It pretty much meets all the qualifications on the bodice ripper checklist. Ridiculously beautiful heroine who almost every man pants after, kidnappings, rape or coerced sex by hero and others, evil villains galore (like the whole world is out to do the heroine wrong), verbally abusive and selfish hero, unpredictable plot with bizarre twists and turns, many scenery changes.
I've only read about 10 of these but I think I would have to go with the Shiek as I read it as a teenager and have fond memories. Gypsy Lady and Lady Vixon were the books that introduced me to the more hard edged BR. Thank you for the list.
Sita wrote: "I would not have considered The Pagan a bodice ripper.."
In my review, I likened Vesuvio the hero to one of those old-school BR heroines who get used and abused. In an odd way, I thought it worked. LOL
In my review, I likened Vesuvio the hero to one of those old-school BR heroines who get used and abused. In an odd way, I thought it worked. LOL
Karla (Mossy Love Grotto) wrote: In my review, I likened Vesuvio the hero to one of those old-school BR heroines who get used and abused. In an odd way, I thou..."I guess that was why I was confused. For me, a man getting used and abused wouldn't fall into the "bodice ripper" category. But that is just me.
In any case. I love the list and am glad a monitored one is here. :D
What about Laurie McBain's Tears of Gold, Devil's Desire and Moonstruck Madness? Lisa Gregory's Bitterleaf dealt with slavery.
Well, I can't vote because I haven't read any of these, but 'down and dirty'? I'm checking the books on the list. Twice.
I'd recommend Silver Jasmine by Janet Louise Roberts. Island of Desire by the same author, now that I reflect on it. Both have rape or attempted rape, Voodoo, abuse, marriage by force, all of that horrifically delicious stuff you find in a good BR.
Thanks for the rec, Stacy. I've got both of those in the TBR. Will add to the list when I'm on an actual computer instead of a tablet (love it, but sometimes so ponderous).
The heart of war by Lisa Beth Darling could be on this list , though it's not from the 70's or 80's , it still has child abuse , humiliation, gore, and the use of a snake to torture. The list goes on but that would be spoilers.
Keri wrote: "What about Laurie McBain's Tears of Gold, Devil's Desire and Moonstruck Madness? Lisa Gregory's Bitterleaf dealt with slavery."Sorry, but Tears of Gold isn't a bodice ripper at all.
What about The French Passion by Diane Du Pont? It was published in 1977 and has a young heroine raped by the hero and kept by an abusive "guardian" as his mistress until he has her imprisoned in the Bastille.
A Pirate's Love, by Johanna Lindsay (h is raped by H, who is a pirate and abducts her)Hearts Aflame, by Johanna Lindsay (h is abducted and made a slave, forced to have sex with H who owns her)
Secret Fire, by Johanna Lindsay (h is abducted and drugged, forced to have sex with Russian aristocrat and basically taken as a slave. She's later whipped for disobedience.)
I added Under Crimson Sails to the list because of the sexual slavery, rape, and sexual depravity the heroine suffered at the hands of every man she came in contact with. XDEdit: Woops, I should learn to read...says not to add books... XD
I am deleting it now, if someone wants to check it out and see if it qualifies.
I TRUST YOU. :D But since you deleted it, I'll add it. I'm super-curious about that one.
It's because my old BR list had every Lindsey & Kleypas imaginable on it. FFS, people. -__-
It's because my old BR list had every Lindsey & Kleypas imaginable on it. FFS, people. -__-
Karla (Mossy Love Grotto) wrote: "I TRUST YOU. :D But since you deleted it, I'll add it. I'm super-curious about that one.It's because my old BR list had every Lindsey & Kleypas imaginable on it. FFS, people. -__-"
XD Good ole JL.... The Quaker's version of BRs. lol I honestly don't even think I've read anything by Kleypas, either. o.o Who..is that?
I haven't read anything by her, but I've got a couple of her early romances that will never see the light of reissue day because they supposedly don't toe the PC line.
However, Kleypas' idea of BR-ness sounds even more tame than JLs. LOL (Quaker's version... *sporfle*)
She's got her devoted fans, though. Regency crap. You know the drill. :P
However, Kleypas' idea of BR-ness sounds even more tame than JLs. LOL (Quaker's version... *sporfle*)
She's got her devoted fans, though. Regency crap. You know the drill. :P
I really think Tame the Rising Tide should be added to this list. I believe it meets a lot of the criteria Heroine is raped gives birth children are stolen away, falls for a man the main Hero,but doesn't stay with him after many men later married to a much older man and raped again she finally finds her way back to her love.
Thanks for the suggestion, Kimberly. I've got that one on the TBR and it certainly looks like it'd qualify. I'll add it. :)
I'm hoping someone here can help me with my search. I remember reading a novel in the mid-90s, so I'm guessing it was a '70s or '80s release date. I remember one of the character's names was Olympia St. James. She was the sister of the abductor. The main character was a young woman from London who did not want to go forward with the arranged marriage her parents set up with an American living near New Orleans. She ran away and ended up on a ship, and fell in love with the captain, who just happened to be her betrothed. When they landed in New Orleans, he left her alone in the hotel, intending to return and tell her who he was. Instead, his cousin, Olympia's brother, abducted the woman. Does this ring a bell for anyone? I haven't read the novel in almost 20 years and would really like to re-read it. Thanks!
Hi Krystle! I think it might be In Passion's Shadow by Sandra Dubay.
There's a partially visible version here which appeared in Google results for Olympia's name.
Another option: You can check the Openlibrary link and see if it's available to borrow (if your state participates in the lending program).
There's a partially visible version here which appeared in Google results for Olympia's name.
Another option: You can check the Openlibrary link and see if it's available to borrow (if your state participates in the lending program).
I'd like to nominate
It's pretty intense. Lots of rape or threats of rape in the beginning. The other love interest gets a hand cut off. And the villain has a necklace woven from the pubes of all the women he's ever slept with.
Id like to nominate
Into Passion's Dawn Across Captive Seas Toward Love's Horizon
I added the series because i haven't read a more violent bodice ripper besides storm fire. The difference is she gives back as good as she gets.
multiple beatings and rapes by different men.
not an easy read. But well worth the experience
I just finished reading the first book in that trilogy and I totally agree.
Karla (Mossy Love Grotto) wrote: "I just finished reading the first book in that trilogy and I totally agree."I think The loves of Angela Carlyle is a very under rated bodice ripper series. It was a very difficult read as she is put through so much violence. But what makes this book stand out from most is that she doesnt seem to swoon for him, instead she fights him, and even shoots him.
Thank you for responding.
I was starting to think i was only person who have read it.
What did you think?
I read it more like a trainwreck. The writing overall left me so cold in spots. There were periods of dullness where I wanted the plot to get moving. But then when Scott would show up, things didn't seem to improve in the drama department beyond simple shock value and repetitious back-and-forth/hot-and-cold fighting. It was a mixed bag, though it reminded me greatly of Savage Surrender in tone and the bone-headed determination of the heroine to keep plugging along through various situations.
By the end Scott was giving off the same vibes as Anthony Welles in Devil's Embrace with his "kidnap and rape you til you realize we're made for each other" attitude. I didn't like that book for a wealth of reasons, so it kind of harshed my buzz towards the finale to be reminded of it.
I'm still going to read the rest of the trilogy, though. I had a take a break from it because it exhausted me with its bludgeoning tone of futile bickering and sexual warfare. I thought Angela was constantly vacillating about him (love-hate-love-hate), which sounds like a different take than what you had.
By the end Scott was giving off the same vibes as Anthony Welles in Devil's Embrace with his "kidnap and rape you til you realize we're made for each other" attitude. I didn't like that book for a wealth of reasons, so it kind of harshed my buzz towards the finale to be reminded of it.
I'm still going to read the rest of the trilogy, though. I had a take a break from it because it exhausted me with its bludgeoning tone of futile bickering and sexual warfare. I thought Angela was constantly vacillating about him (love-hate-love-hate), which sounds like a different take than what you had.
I'm familiar with Silken Savage, but what elements make Silver Jasmine bodice rippery?
If I recall correctly (it's been ages since I read it), the hero wins the heroine in a card game, rapes her, then takes her to America to live on a southern plantation. I think one of the secondary characters is also raped later in the story. There's slavery, murder, and violence, especially against women.I may not be remembering this bit right or I could be confusing it with another book I read, but I think one of the female characters (a slave) is either scarred on her face or else scarred in some way so that she can't have children. I think the former plantation owner or overseer did this to her.
Like I said, I could be confusing this with another book. I don't have a copy of this anymore, so I can't fact-check. Sorry!
I think I have a copy, so I'll thumb through it to make sure, but it sounds good! I'll add it anyway and edit if necessary. :)
I can't believe I'm missing out on these great books just because it's written decades before me. :( These books aren't available in print now..... I'm just dissapointed there's no way I can read this unless it's for sale in amazon or something
Some of them can be had at book sales or used book stores, if you have those options in your area. Thriftbooks and Abebooks are also good online sources! And the internet has quite a few of the permanently-out-of-print pricey ones. ;)
The Masquers by Natasha Peters These Golden Pleasures by Valerie Sherwood
Jasmine on Wind by Mallory Dorn Hart
So Wild a Rapture by Andrea Layton
Lovesong (Song Trilogy #1) by Valerie Sherwood
Imperial Nights by Olivia O'Neill
Dare to Love by Jennifer Wilde
Elena by Marilyn Granbeck
I wanna say "LOVE, WILD AND FAIR". But i understand if you don't wanna add it... Not as " SKYE O'MALLEY" seems to be more what your looking for. Maybe i am remembering it wrong but cat certainaly gets passed around a fair bit! OMG! OMG! I forgot to say by bertrice small!! (But i feel like skye omalley is a pretty well known book!! No?)














I hope I'm not being an asshole by saying "DON'T ADD TO THIS LIST!" but I'd like to be able to mod this one at least a little bit. :P
Anyway, if you want to add a book, post a comment with a couple reason why you think it qualifies.
TO REITERATE:
Suggested reasons (and a high or intense quantity of them is encouraged)
--rape
--gang rape
--multiple abuses by hero (a slap doesn't count)
--slavery & the abuses/degradation that come with it
--incest
--child abuse
--random extreme stuff like castration (Hello, Stormfire!)
--very under-aged heroines
--violence and/or gore