Best M/M historical romance
Comments Showing 1-47 of 47 (47 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Jul 18, 2009 08:46AM
I've got to do some reading so I can post to this list. The only historicals that I've read that aren't het are mmf.
reply
|
flag
Marilla, there are some great books on this list! I recommend Ava March! She's awesome.
Barbara wrote: ""Wicked Gentlemen" is definitely not a historical romance, it's a fantasy."You're correct Barbara so I've removed it from the list.
I deleted the interloper book from the list. Anyone with a legitimate account that wants to vote for it again may do so.
A Midwinter Prince is not historical either, it has computers and cellphones etc. It is a good book, but it doesn't belong on this list.
I wrote an article about m/m historical then whined about not being able to find a place to link to it here at goodreads. Shannon pointed me to this thread. http://www.heroesandheartbreakers.com...
Just a silly comment...Secret Light is listed here as "Historical". It's set in 1955. I was born before then, so logically I am also "Historical"...which I find hysterical! LOL!
Bookbee wrote: "Just a silly comment...Secret Light is listed here as "Historical". It's set in 1955. I was born before then, so logically I am also "Historical"...which I find hysterical! LOL!"
Vintage. I think anyone born before 1960 is considered vintage, like a really nice wine.
Kate wrote: "Vintage. I think anyone born before 1960 is considered vintage, like a really nice wine."Oh, I like that MUCH better!
Mongrel by KZ Snow isn't a historical. It's more fantasy/steampunk in an AU world with special beings.
The Steel Remains (A Land Fit for Heroes, #1)by Richard K. Morgan - Fantasy and there's no romance
Every Good Thing by M. Jules Aedin - Fantasy
Like the Taste of Summer by Kaje Harper - Are the 1980s considered historical now?
What a wonderful list.. Come visit Our Story GLBTQ Historical Fiction at www.glbtbooksshelf.com for more historical titles.
Hmmm... it appears the typo monster is at work...http://www.glbtbookshelf.com
You can also just Google GLBT Bookshelf.
Just look for the OUr Story banner on the page.
Hey, by the way... we are looking for reviews of FLBT historical fiction.. anyone wanna join the merry crew?
that one works!! Christopher Hawthorne wrote: "Hmmm... it appears the typo monster is at work...http://www.glbtbookshelf.com"
Since it looks like this story is set in the year 2040, wouldn't this fit better in a sci-fI category?http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/16...
Rosa wrote: "'The Man Who Fell in Love with the Moon' and 'Fingersmith' should be on this list. I highly recommend them. Also 'Fingersmith' was made into a BBC costume drama, which is also worth watching.
http..."
You can add them to the list.
http..."
You can add them to the list.
Pwnn wrote: "The Steel Remains (A Land Fit for Heroes, #1)by Richard K. Morgan - Fantasy and there's no romance
Every Good Thing by M. Jules Aedin - Fantasy
Like the Taste of Summer by Kaje Harper - Are th..."
Agree with the Steel Remains it's a fantasy/sci fi mix, and far from romance.
242 Wicked Gentlemen by Ginn Hale is amazing but it is so far into Alternate Universe with ghetto-bound Prodigals = demons that I don't think it belongs with historicals.
This list would be, oh, a million times more useful to my life without the fantasy novels cluttering it up. If it was just, you know, HISTORICAL FICTION. Sigh.ETA I'd love to look at a list for Fantasy M/M, for the record. I'd just appreciate separate lists.
Brideshead Revisited (#176) was published in 1945, so it's not exactly an historical novel... Same goes for The Picture of Dorian Gray (#209) which was first published in 1890.
This list has become a weird mix. I don't think publication date should define if it belongs in the historical romance, but the context of the romance story. All the KJ Charles stories listed are fantasy (except Think of England and the Society of Gentlemen series(e.g., A Fashionable Indulgence)), as are all the Jordan Hawk books. Can these be cleared out?
This list would be helped very much by some boundaries to the definition of historical romance...a lot of romances set in historical times (earlier than 1900 ) are not usually very clear about what era or year they are set in, though (e.g., Regency, Victorian, etc.), so I wouldn't be too bounded!
To address this, the opening list-defining paragraph could be expanded to say that the list is looking for "mm romance stories set in historical contexts . Magical, fantasy and paranormal stories, even if they have an historical feel, should not be included here."
WMD wrote: "This list has become a weird mix. I don't think publication date should define if it belongs in the historical romance, but the context of the romance story. All the KJ Charles stories listed are..."
Listopia lists are defined by the creator of the list and generally edited by the creator, so unless the creator comes back and re-defines the list, it won't change.
A list like you have described would be useful. Perhaps you could consider starting one?
We can adjust the list if it is not correct - librarian's have editing privileges - however w/o the originator defining the specifics I personally don't usually edit. Because I do not know the intention. I removed Last Call which is most definitely not historical. Not sure why it was on here.
# 262 - as much as I love Luck in the Shadows it is high fantasy, not even AU historical; same for Kim Fielding's The Pillar at 307
Booklovinglady wrote: "Brideshead Revisited (#176) was published in 1945, so it's not exactly an historical novel... Same goes for The Picture of Dorian Gray (#209) which was first published in 1..."There is a difference between 'historical' novels/romance and just 'old' novels/romance... At least there is in my book.
Where are they now?-hope they are well. . .Writers I haven't had a historical / fantastical mm book from in a very, very long time. Have they stopped writing historical / fantastical mm?
Peeps, feel free to add to this list.
Erastes
Eresse
DarkEmeralds (fan fic only?)
Rowena Sudbury
Dawn Douglas
Andrew Ashling
Farida Mestek
Ava March
Alana Ankh
Laylah Hunter
Lydia Gastrell
J. L. Langley
Jess Faraday (historical mm)
Nancy M. Griffis
Tyler Flynn
Gil Cole (only 1 book?)
J. Roman
Anel Viz
Lynn Lorenz
MJ Pearson
Jamie Fessenden
I bet there are lots more authors who haven't published a historical / fantastical mm story in a while. Here's hoping they're all well and will bring us joy once more.
Kragthang wrote: "Hexbreaker by Jordan L. Hawk is twice in the list. On page 4 and page 7."Shouldn't be, as the duplicate check (for librarians) came up with nothing.
Which numbers?
@BooklovingladyThanks for checking. Maybe someone else already took care of it.
I voted for both books and today only one vote is visible. I also scrolled through the pages and could only find one book today.
Tamara (緑) wrote: "Captive Prince isn't historical, it's fantasy. It shouldn't be on this list."I can remove it if you like, just give me the number the book is on. (I had a look at your profile; you can just as easily remove it yourself, as you are a GR librarian too...)
From the books on this list that I've read, a huge number are not historical, but are fantasy, sf, paranormal, or set in other universes.
I don't even know if I can list them all, there are so many.
Starting with the first few:
Numbers 1, 2, 5, 7, 8, 9, 14, 18, 30, 36, 44, 74, 77, 90, 96, 103, 105, 121, 134, 183, 190, 195, 214, 225, 251, 272, 283, 284, 302, 317, 334, 336, 366, 372, 292, 295, 414, 452, 503, 517... and it goes on and on.
All the books by Jordan Hawk are fantasy. Some books by KJ Charles. There are several time travel books on this list that obviously don't belong there. The Captive Prince books and some books by Megan Derr are fantasy. And those are just the books I've read. Some look like fantasy, just by their covers.
This list needs a total overhaul to come anywhere close to accurate.
I don't even know if I can list them all, there are so many.
Starting with the first few:
Numbers 1, 2, 5, 7, 8, 9, 14, 18, 30, 36, 44, 74, 77, 90, 96, 103, 105, 121, 134, 183, 190, 195, 214, 225, 251, 272, 283, 284, 302, 317, 334, 336, 366, 372, 292, 295, 414, 452, 503, 517... and it goes on and on.
All the books by Jordan Hawk are fantasy. Some books by KJ Charles. There are several time travel books on this list that obviously don't belong there. The Captive Prince books and some books by Megan Derr are fantasy. And those are just the books I've read. Some look like fantasy, just by their covers.
This list needs a total overhaul to come anywhere close to accurate.
Sara wrote: "From the books on this list that I've read, a huge number are not historical, but are fantasy, sf, paranormal, or set in other universes.I don't even know if I can list them all, there are so many..."
Agreed! I enjoy fantasy MM romance too but they do not belong on this list! If there is a librarian available to correct this list, I could enumerate all the non-historicals I am aware of here.
While I appreciate the existence of lists like this, it's unfortunate that there's zero quality control in place. This list pops up as being 'the best' compilation of gay historical romance but I feel it doesn't come close to earning that title. Many books aren't historical romance - I saw classics, historical fiction, gay historical fiction, fantasy, alternate reality etc. I also noticed there are a lot of books from the early period of MM romance publishing (2009-2012), which produced some winners but only represents a tiny slice of what the MM historical romance genre has turned into.
Related News
Good news, romance readers. The new year is about to get spicy!
Or steamy. Could be steamy. Actually, insert your own wink-nudge euphemism...
Anyone can add books to this list.

















