Score

Aren't frogs amphibians?

True. Removed them, one and all!

Thank you!

Cindy wrote: "Thank you!"

salamanders are amphibians also. Where do you stand on dragons ?

If the dragon is pictured on the book and it looks like a reptile, I'd say it counts. If it looks like a mythological beast, it doesn't. If it's just a title like "Calling on Dragons", then it doesn't count. But if the story contains a dragon that is a reptile, then it would count. Hope that's not too confusing.

Cindy wrote: "If the dragon is pictured on the book and it looks like a reptile, I'd say it counts. If it looks like a mythological beast, it doesn't. If it's just a title like "Calling on Dragons", then it doe..."

Not too, dragons were often called "wyrms". I think in the film, Dragonslayer, the baby dragons hatch from eggs....If it walks like a reptile, and quacks like a reptile.....

I'm just thinking that we already have plenty of lists with dragons on them. I don't think we need to add them unless they are here in their reptile guise.

Cindy wrote: "I'm just thinking that we already have plenty of lists with dragons on them. I don't think we need to add them unless they are here in their reptile guise."

Right. I'm thinking that calling a dragon a lizard would be some kind of major insult.

Thom wrote: salamanders are amphibians also."

Got rid of salamander. (Sigh.)

SSSSSSSSSSplendid whoever nominated Belgariad #2.

[image error]

Got dinosaurs on the list.

Bettie wrote: "SSSSSSSSSSplendid whoever nominated Belgariad #2.

"



"Now if your lordship would turn your attention to this next book, your lordship might indeed come across a personality that would appear to be vaguely familiar ..."

Cindy wrote: "Got dinosaurs on the list."

My bad.... didn't read the restrictive clause.

What about Wind in the Willows? If it's Toad that put the book on the list, toads are amphibians.

Cindy wrote: "What about Wind in the Willows? If it's Toad that put the book on the list, toads are amphibians."

True dat.

I removed The Wind in the Willows since Toad is an amphibian.

Thanks