Mjarchitect asked Tana French:

One of the great things about your books is the setting and culture of Ireland. Given your background, do different cultures have different tendencies toward violence? In other words, if your setting was somewhere else would your stories be different? Regards, MJ

Tana French I think the stories would definitely be different if they were set in another time and/or place. Murder happens everywhere, but the reasons for it vary wildly, and they say a lot about the society in which the murder is committed - its priorities, its fears, its taboos and its dark places. The murder in Faithful Place stems to a large extent from a very Irish sense of family - it might not happen in a more individualistic society. In Broken Harbour, the murder grows out of the insanity that enveloped much of the country during the Celtic Tiger, and the devastation it left in its wake - it wouldn't have happened in another place or even a few years earlier. In the mystery novels I love best, the murder becomes a window into the heart of the society where it happens.

flag