Moiraine

Add friend
Sign in to Goodreads to learn more about Moiraine.


Tea & Alchemy
Moiraine is currently reading
by Sharon Lynn Fisher (Goodreads Author)
bookshelves: currently-reading
Rate this book
Clear rating

 
In the Veins of t...
Moiraine is currently reading
by Kalie Cassidy (Goodreads Author)
bookshelves: currently-reading
Rate this book
Clear rating

 
FBI Dragon Chroni...
Moiraine is currently reading
by J.L. Hendricks (Goodreads Author)
bookshelves: currently-reading
Rate this book
Clear rating

 
See all 18 books that Moiraine is reading…
Loading...
“Debbie Nathan also puts a great deal of weight on a letter from Shirley Mason to Dr. Wilbur stating that her MPD was made up. Dr. Wilbur’s explanation was that the letter was based on resistance. Debbie Nathan takes the letter as a statement of the real truth. But if Shirley Mason was such an unreliable historian of her own trauma and mental health history, why should we take this single letter as the truth? If a person with a long history of treatment for alcoholism wrote a letter to her psychiatrist, in the middle of treatment, saying that she did not have a drinking problem, what would we conclude?”
Colin A. Ross

As a single case from half a century ago, Sybil Exposed cannot tell us anything
“As a single case from half a century ago, Sybil Exposed cannot tell us anything about the reliability, validity, etiology, epidemiology, or typical treatment outcome of a mental disorder.

Nathan’s alternative theory of pernicious anemia is implausible and supported by no corroborating evidence; Debbie Nathan advocates a hypothetical explanation of Shirley’s pre-1945 symptoms that is less evidence based than the trauma dissociation theory she rejects.”
Colin A. Ross

Angie Sage
“They would all be sorry... particularly the duck.”
Angie Sage

Angie Sage
“...yelling doesn't make a thing any more possible.”
Angie Sage, Queste

“A problem is that Nathan documents Shirley Mason as suffering from a variety of symptoms of a complex dissociative disorder prior to her first contact with Dr. Wilbur, although Nathan denies the dissociative nature of these symptoms. The symptoms described as real by Debbie Nathan include fugue states; blank spells; spending hours playing with imaginary companions with names far beyond the age when this occurs in nontraumatized children; pretending to be “Vicky,” one of her “imaginary companions” at times; her mother calling her by the same names of alter personalities later identified in adult therapy; talking in a high, childish voice when she was no longer a child; numerous symptoms consistent with somatoform dissociation throughout her childhood and adulthood; going downtown to bars to drink with men and not remembering afterward; suddenly becoming comatose in public; and suddenly acting dramatically out of character. All of these symptoms were described to Debbie Nathan in interviews with people who knew Shirley Mason well. Thus, Debbie Nathan’s book actually inadvertently provides documentation of a range of psychological and physical symptoms that would be expected beginning in childhood for someone with a burgeoning dissociative disorder.”
Colin A. Ross

56898 Shut Up & Read — 9894 members — last activity 7 hours, 7 min ago
A place for all types of readers.
year in books
Emilia
617 books | 683 friends

Dale Te...
4 books | 44 friends

Dana Ross
1 book | 7 friends

Elaine
160 books | 1 friend

Donna G...
2 books | 48 friends

Bruce A...
0 books | 152 friends

Ed
Ed
2,206 books | 5,035 friends

Bob
Bob
0 books | 9 friends

More friends…



Polls voted on by Moiraine

Lists liked by Moiraine