Melanie’s Reviews > Sunrise on the Reaping > Status Update
Melanie
is on page 23 of 387
I do NOT buy the retrofitting of characters into this book, esp the Covey but also Katniss's parents.
— Sep 26, 2025 12:10PM
Like flag
Melanie’s Previous Updates
Melanie
is on page 178 of 387
Weird to read so much about a plan that I know (from reading the other books) does not actually come to pass (unless Collins forgot what she wrote before).
— Sep 27, 2025 08:58PM
Melanie
is on page 108 of 387
How could haymitch possibly know who beetee is, when haymitch is 16 and beetee is old enough to have a 13 year old child in the games? Beetee would have won before Haymitch was sentient.
— Sep 27, 2025 02:12PM
