Melanie’s Reviews > Sunrise on the Reaping > Status Update
Melanie
is on page 178 of 387
Weird to read so much about a plan that I know (from reading the other books) does not actually come to pass (unless Collins forgot what she wrote before).
— Sep 27, 2025 08:58PM
Like flag
Melanie’s Previous Updates
Melanie
is on page 108 of 387
How could haymitch possibly know who beetee is, when haymitch is 16 and beetee is old enough to have a 13 year old child in the games? Beetee would have won before Haymitch was sentient.
— Sep 27, 2025 02:12PM
Melanie
is on page 23 of 387
I do NOT buy the retrofitting of characters into this book, esp the Covey but also Katniss's parents.
— Sep 26, 2025 12:10PM
