Em’s Reviews > The Rose Field > Status Update
Em
is on page 143
Anyone out there reading this: What on earth is happening with these windows? This seems like a major inconsistency with book 3. Has anyone figured this out? Please! (And I don't mind spoilers at this point--I thought they had to be closed. I thought they were ALL closed).
— Oct 25, 2025 07:43PM
4 likes · Like flag
Em’s Previous Updates
Em
is on page 112
Pullman is just so brilliant; my awe over his prose--the variation of character voices and all the local color in their speech patterns--the complexity of his world building which is pretty much unequalled--defies a solid brief comment.
— Oct 25, 2025 07:03PM
Em
is on page 82
But I thought all the windows were closed by divine forces in book 3?!
And...why does Lyra always have to lose her compass?
*Had to start this book the second it arrived, but now I'm splitting time b/n two incredible fantasy reads. What a wonderful problem to have!
— Oct 25, 2025 09:06AM
And...why does Lyra always have to lose her compass?
*Had to start this book the second it arrived, but now I'm splitting time b/n two incredible fantasy reads. What a wonderful problem to have!
