Kitty Thomas’s Reviews > Blackthorn > Status Update

I have this deluxe special edition as a trophy.

so... I'll be honest, rereading this... Geissinger is either a genius or wrote a structurally broken story. The naturalistic explanation has too many plot holes, loose threads, major major freaking problems. The supernatural reading is coherent, everything ties up neatly, nothing is left dangling. I'm still siding with the supernatural plot is the real plot and the naturalistic tagged on explanation is a cover story.

Yes, I'm starting a re-read of this right after I finished it. I need to experience it again, knowing the facts I know now about the ending so I can process it.