Ada’s Reviews > An Atlas of Tolkien > Status Update
Ada
is on page 144 of 256
Did I miss when or where the Hobbits came from? Apparently they started in the First Age but on the genealogy pages they are never mentioned?!
Listen, I only care about the Hobbits. Cliché but true.
— Dec 06, 2025 02:46AM
Listen, I only care about the Hobbits. Cliché but true.
Like flag
Ada’s Previous Updates
Ada
is on page 181 of 256
"So it was that the meekest and least of all people came to hold the gate of all the world in their hands."
MEEKEST? LEAST OF ALL PEOPLE? According to who?! Dude. I would have said comfortable, content with their lot in life, even closed off to the rest of the world or a bit xenophobic.
But meek? Least of all people? That sounds so insulting!
— Dec 06, 2025 02:57AM
MEEKEST? LEAST OF ALL PEOPLE? According to who?! Dude. I would have said comfortable, content with their lot in life, even closed off to the rest of the world or a bit xenophobic.
But meek? Least of all people? That sounds so insulting!
Ada
is on page 152 of 256
Wauw. So literally nothing is known about them huh.
This is disappointing.
— Dec 06, 2025 02:49AM
This is disappointing.
Ada
is on page 128 of 256
I am always a bit amused seeing the word 'barbarians' used in the context of Tolkien's work. He was a language nerd but the word 'barbarian' has such a specific origin that it feels a bit out of place because it does not have the same history in the world he created.
It is a quibble but I would have loved to ask him about these kinds of things because he loved language so much.
— Dec 06, 2025 02:34AM
It is a quibble but I would have loved to ask him about these kinds of things because he loved language so much.
Ada
is starting
I have lost the book. No idea where it is. Which is unlike me.
How do you lose a whole ass book?!
— Nov 22, 2025 12:40PM
How do you lose a whole ass book?!
