Samar El’s Reviews > Circe > Status Update

Samar El
Samar El is on page 155 of 393
Whenever Circe talks with her siblings, I’m always so confused on the attitude and emotions being conveyed. Not because of the writing, just the way immoral beings talk to one another like nothing matters.

Grateful for Hermes being the gossip for Circe, yet we see how she doesn’t feel connected to him, how his hands are too clean and unscarred. She really does have a type, mortals.
Jan 19, 2026 04:18AM
Circe

flag

Samar’s Previous Updates

Samar El
Samar El is on page 281 of 393
I’m way more than 70% through this book but that’s neither here or there.

I forgot to mention how much of a badass Circe has become. Seeing her grow not only from being with her abusive family but from when she first arrived on the island.
Jan 24, 2026 03:29AM
Circe


Samar El
Samar El is on page 275 of 393
Penelope and Telemachus arrived at Aiaia and…. Odysseus is dead. That grand, witty and mighty Odysseus got pricked by a tail and went down. It’s obviously more than that but considering he’s been a horrible king, husband and father…I don’t feel bad.

Poor Telegonus though, when he got back to the island he’s just a ball of tears. Made me so sad he’s just a baby compared to everyone.
Jan 23, 2026 04:25AM
Circe


Samar El
Samar El is on page 249 of 393
Circe and Telegonus. Witch mother, demigod son, hunted by Athena for reasons unknown and known…

Reading these mother and son moments got me feeling a range of emotions. Circe hasn’t had a moments rest because he’s a mortal baby. Telegonus is an annoying baby.

Athena threatens to kill him, offering Circe a favour from the goddess herself yet Circe stands by her baby. Respect.
Jan 22, 2026 04:25AM
Circe


Samar El
Samar El is on page 209 of 393
Circe got into a habit of just turning any traveler to her island into pigs. Fair enough, considering how their demeanour changes straight away learning she’s alone.

I love the way Madeline writes the storyline, including moments that are relevant and forcing me to read carefully.

Odysseus left his mark with Circe, I liked what they did for eachother and how Madeline wrote their time together.
Jan 21, 2026 04:08AM
Circe


Samar El
Samar El is on page 167 of 393
Damn this chapter hurt.
Her lioness died, as did I reading that passage.
Aiaia is now a recreation island for disobedient daughters….
Men took advantage of Circes hospitality and is most definitely the reason why she likes to turn any men into pigs.

What a ride.
Jan 20, 2026 05:19AM
Circe


Samar El
Samar El is on page 133 of 393
I really couldn’t put that book down. Circe is only ever interested in either Mortals or Olympian Gods, and she gets them.

Leaving her island, facing Scylla and her sister, showing off her new transformed self. Pun intended. Circe, the way that you’re approaching life, before the lecture from your sister, is admirable.

Recognising mortals as people and rejecting their praise to you. Respect.
Jan 18, 2026 04:48AM
Circe


Samar El
Samar El is on page 89 of 393
Yessss Circe, you’re growing into the Witch your brother has been waiting for. I like the way Madeline Miller describes how Circe came to her powers. The trial and error, the learning and feeling for what speaks to her.

Hermes’ and Circe are together for a bit? Not bad, happy Circe is getting some while she’s in Exile. Also, a pet lion is so fun.
Jan 17, 2026 05:38AM
Circe


Samar El
Samar El is on page 67 of 393
Circe, you’re naive, weak minded and a little stupid for confessing. However, I see why you confessed, I see why you changed that buffoon into a god, I see why you can’t stand up for yourself.

I’m ready for your training arc on that island you’re banished to. Turn you into that strong witch I know you can be.
Jan 16, 2026 04:38AM
Circe


Samar El
Samar El is on page 41 of 393
I’m proud of myself for being able to understand the timeline of Circes story with the events of other titans and gods around.

Going into this fully blind to the pre Odysseus moments of Circe. I’m enjoying her heartbreaking upbringing, scared to read on because I know she’s been betrayed and loved before.
Jan 15, 2026 04:11AM
Circe


No comments have been added yet.