W’s Reviews > The Lord of the Rings > Status Update
W
is on page 686 of 1216
Frodo has a lot more doubt and clarity over Gollum than is portrayed in the film(s).
Merry and Pippin may be perceived as plucky comic relief but Samwise The Stouthearted is hilarious, especially when talking to someone of higher rank, and never failing to tell of the pearls of wisdom his Ol' Gaffer states on every occasion.
— Jan 20, 2026 01:19PM
Merry and Pippin may be perceived as plucky comic relief but Samwise The Stouthearted is hilarious, especially when talking to someone of higher rank, and never failing to tell of the pearls of wisdom his Ol' Gaffer states on every occasion.
Like flag
W’s Previous Updates
W
is on page 938 of 1216
Again - despite knowing the story I am so gripped by it.
I am hanging on the stories they're sharing amongst themselves, despite having just read them all myself - it has also given me an appreciation of the decisions Jackson made in the films to give moments more resonance et cetera.
Might finish it completely tonight. I think ROTK might be the best book..... It's tough.
— Jan 25, 2026 01:56PM
I am hanging on the stories they're sharing amongst themselves, despite having just read them all myself - it has also given me an appreciation of the decisions Jackson made in the films to give moments more resonance et cetera.
Might finish it completely tonight. I think ROTK might be the best book..... It's tough.
