JoanaPP’s Reviews > Shadow Reaper > Status Update
JoanaPP
is 53% done
I am confused as to how the siphon from one to one work because if the group (iykyk) is siphoning from one another, won't they just run out of said magic? how much magic would they have had to taken in the past for it to linger that long?
— Jan 24, 2026 07:32AM
Like flag
JoanaPP’s Previous Updates
JoanaPP
is 58% done
(Spoilers) Who’s buried in the necropolis? Why is it there? Is Kadmus involved?
— Jan 25, 2026 10:06PM
JoanaPP
is 58% done
What if there’s a scene in which Viri has to go through the “anniversary” of her Impartation? Especially if she’s caged by Brae. That would be gut-wrenching
— Jan 25, 2026 10:02PM
JoanaPP
is 58% done
The book answers questions I wouldn’t have even thought to ask, and I love it.
What if (spoilers) when the obelisks are broken, the mist doesn’t invade the isle at once but is moving ever so slowly because of Brae waiting for the comet for another reason altogether?
— Jan 25, 2026 09:58PM
What if (spoilers) when the obelisks are broken, the mist doesn’t invade the isle at once but is moving ever so slowly because of Brae waiting for the comet for another reason altogether?
JoanaPP
is 57% done
I love this hero goes against the laws because the laws prevent him from doing what’s right.
— Jan 25, 2026 09:57PM
JoanaPP
is 57% done
How does wayportaling feel for a person? Because it’s a transfer of matter, it should, I don’t know, maybe tingle or something of the kind.
When Meera walked in the office, maybe it would make more sense if she didn’t say anything as her line of sight wasn’t on them, but on the papers. As it’s been explained, it doesn’t work on people behind her (aka the Nox), so that’s okay for confidentiality.
— Jan 25, 2026 09:55PM
When Meera walked in the office, maybe it would make more sense if she didn’t say anything as her line of sight wasn’t on them, but on the papers. As it’s been explained, it doesn’t work on people behind her (aka the Nox), so that’s okay for confidentiality.
JoanaPP
is 57% done
(More spoilers) However, that makes Brae have two options: steal the two other talismans (or one as he's one person) or track down Reeve. Which can put in another conflict of them running into one another? And what if one of the rings is gold-rune, the other is silver? How would they work then??
— Jan 25, 2026 03:00PM
JoanaPP
is 57% done
(Spoiler) I have a suggestion. What if the rings aren't exactly a set? What if they are a set but in specific pairs. Like two, for example? In that way, maybe Reeve stole the one from Brae and got captured. Then, he gets the attention of Viri, and they find the other ring (that is a pair of those two-because the runes on one of the pairs are gold; on the other-silver?)
— Jan 25, 2026 02:59PM
JoanaPP
is 56% done
(Spoiler) Why doesn’t Muriel know Viri’s a fugitive if she’s a judge?
— Jan 25, 2026 12:03PM

