Elmo’s Reviews > Soul of a Witch > Status Update
Elmo
is on page 158 of 591
Two of my three questions have already been answered. I’m still unsure about the house he was supposedly “trapped” in—I don’t think he was trapped at all, but waiting for Everly. I’m not completely sure, and it may be explained later. Everly is already growing as a character, Callum is basically a giant German Shepherd puppy, and her grandma is hilarious. Together, they had me laughing so hard I can't barely breathe.
— Jan 28, 2026 11:57AM
Like flag
Elmo’s Previous Updates
Elmo
is on page 335 of 591
Well... I found a my first ick that I didn't know that I had in one of the spicy scenes. It nothing crazy or to out there for a dark romance reader, but as a germaphobe it does get to me. It is probably the most normal thing I have read but we all have our things.
Overall, everything else that is happening currently is amazing. We are seeing growth in both of the characters and a lot of feelings being unboxed.
— Feb 03, 2026 06:55AM
Overall, everything else that is happening currently is amazing. We are seeing growth in both of the characters and a lot of feelings being unboxed.
Elmo
is on page 293 of 591
On the brink of death, Everly summons Callum. Saving her requires a bargain—one that forces Callum to choose between everything he has tried to forget and the woman he can't bear to lose. As the weight of that decision settles in, the wounds he carried home from the war begin to resurface. Old feelings demand to be acknowledged, trust must be rebuilt, and as Everly's time is running out. Callum takes to training her.
— Feb 02, 2026 06:10AM
Elmo
is on page 230 of 591
Everly has escape all alone while Callum is in a prison. He can't leave because it was created by Lu specifically for him. Lu seems to be tired of not having his favorite toy.
Callum in prison did help Everly learn a little more about her witch powers, but also open up a lot of questions for her along with a little bit of danger. Unfortunately, Everly doesn't know Callum is in prison so she is losing trust in him.
— Feb 01, 2026 11:53AM
Callum in prison did help Everly learn a little more about her witch powers, but also open up a lot of questions for her along with a little bit of danger. Unfortunately, Everly doesn't know Callum is in prison so she is losing trust in him.
Elmo
is on page 193 of 591
I’m concerned for Callum. I think Lu is going to take him away from Everly. How is he supposed to protect her if he gets kidnapped? It could increase Everly’s confidence, but it could also destroy some of the trust she has in Callum.
Everly’s father makes me furious. I thought my hatred for him was unmatched in the last two books, but seeing what he’s doing from the inside ignites a whole new level of rage.
— Jan 30, 2026 06:32AM
Everly’s father makes me furious. I thought my hatred for him was unmatched in the last two books, but seeing what he’s doing from the inside ignites a whole new level of rage.
Elmo
is on page 82 of 591
This book has been fun to read. I’m not very far in, but I already love both characters. There’s a lot more mystery compared to the other two books, and I’m excited to see the secrets unfold.
Main Questions:
Why is Callum a guardian to her family?
Why did her mom never take her to the house?
Did he choose to be a guardian, or was it forced?
Why was he trapped in the house until another witch arrived?
— Jan 27, 2026 10:14AM
Main Questions:
Why is Callum a guardian to her family?
Why did her mom never take her to the house?
Did he choose to be a guardian, or was it forced?
Why was he trapped in the house until another witch arrived?
