shaggy’s Reviews > She Started It > Status Update
shaggy
is 37% done
So... Theory: Poppy surely killed herself, and her sister Wendy is taking revenge. The End.
Even if the story is fairly obvious so far, I'm still engaged with how terrible everyone is being. A solid, brutal, bloody ending will convince me to add an extra star to my mental rating.
— Feb 02, 2026 12:55AM
Even if the story is fairly obvious so far, I'm still engaged with how terrible everyone is being. A solid, brutal, bloody ending will convince me to add an extra star to my mental rating.
Like flag
shaggy’s Previous Updates
shaggy
is 52% done
Why are we bothering to look for this crazy bitch now instead of just getting off this island
I think I hate this book
— Feb 02, 2026 09:58AM
I think I hate this book
shaggy
is 50% done
These paybacks feel wildly disproportionate. Esther is completely fucked. But also I really don't give a shit about any of them, not even potentially fake Poppy.
I don't understand the impulse when your battery still has 10% to just give in and get drunk instead of first walking to the top of the cliff to see if you can get a better signal at the very least. They're too stupid to live.
— Feb 02, 2026 09:48AM
I don't understand the impulse when your battery still has 10% to just give in and get drunk instead of first walking to the top of the cliff to see if you can get a better signal at the very least. They're too stupid to live.
shaggy
is 18% done
I know everyone is going to be horrible in this, and it's just a race to see which of them is the lesser evil.
Odds so far:
100 on Esther
50 on Tanya
-5 on Poppy
-100 on Chloe
-1000 on Annabel
-1500 on Annabel's trash husband
The only ones that are currently blameless are Robin the water taxi driver, and Annabel's mother
But I have my eye on Robin just cuz
— Feb 01, 2026 11:48PM
Odds so far:
100 on Esther
50 on Tanya
-5 on Poppy
-100 on Chloe
-1000 on Annabel
-1500 on Annabel's trash husband
The only ones that are currently blameless are Robin the water taxi driver, and Annabel's mother
But I have my eye on Robin just cuz
