Mary Kosanke’s Reviews > In Five Years > Status Update
Mary Kosanke
is on page 145 of 272
GAAAHHHHHH still a page turner. Holy cow.
I can feel they’re leaving out David quite a bit. I didn’t understand why Ariel and someone else were included in the beach trip and hardly mentioned. Beach trip felt cut short and David wasn’t present (1/2)
— Feb 07, 2026 06:09PM
I can feel they’re leaving out David quite a bit. I didn’t understand why Ariel and someone else were included in the beach trip and hardly mentioned. Beach trip felt cut short and David wasn’t present (1/2)
Like flag
Mary’s Previous Updates
Mary Kosanke
is on page 200 of 272
What happened to the girl who was so meticulous about numbers in the first chapter. Everything down to the minute. Now she’s planning a wedding on a whim at the last second? Doesn’t put much energy into buying a wedding dress? Doesn’t care where or when she gets married? Is this the same person?
— Feb 11, 2026 09:57AM
Mary Kosanke
is on page 200 of 272
Why are we still neglecting David’s plot line. Author is just going to drop that he has that look in his eyes and ignore it for many chapters?? Just a quick chapter in LA and then suddenly back in NYC??? So much is being left out. It feels so rushed with wedding planning too. Is the loft the same party she sees in the dream??
— Feb 11, 2026 09:55AM
Mary Kosanke
is on page 145 of 272
2/2 Why hasn’t Bella asked Dannie why she calls Greg, Aaron. It also feels like a similar build up to “expiration dates”. I’m guessing she dumps David due to being overworked? Bella dies and then Dannie and Aaron bond over all losses? GAH
— Feb 07, 2026 06:09PM
Mary Kosanke
is on page 68 of 272
Um. Wow. 0-100 real quick. Quite the opening. But also why did we just skip a whole 4.5 years like it was nothing? Just a few sentences when she started out the book with minute by minute detail. Seems rushed to get to wherever we’re going so far. It is a page turner
— Feb 07, 2026 11:45AM
