Freya’s Reviews > Eclipse > Status Update
Freya
is 50% done
It's weird that Charlie will never take Bella's side when her and Jacob argue, and he doesn't ask about what happened. If he did, he would know that Jacob told her she's better off dead, she's an idiot, and he also assaults her. Jacob and Edward are the two guys you hate to be around, one is insecure and needs you to validate him, the other is nonchalant TM.
— Feb 26, 2026 04:26PM
Like flag
Freya’s Previous Updates
Freya
is 60% done
I knew that Jacob kissed Bella to prove that she was in denial about loving him but that was the most triggering sequence of conversations and I dare to say, the movie did it a lot better. Charlie takes some massive Ls in this book- like when he finds out Bella hit Jacob after he kissed her, and Charlie just goes "atta boy make your move son, don't mind my silly girl."
— Feb 26, 2026 10:12PM
Freya
is 20% done
For all the "problematic" stuff in Twilight, one thing that I've never heard anyone talk about is Jacob aging 10 years after turning into a werewolf. He's "physically grown to 25." Age gap relationships are endlessly critiqued in vampire fiction (I'm personally laissez-faire about it) and yet no one questions Jacob being 25. Idk, is he MENTALLY 25??
— Feb 25, 2026 05:15PM
