Amanda Smith’s Reviews > Harrow the Ninth > Status Update
Amanda Smith
is 18% done
I'm really glad we're on a bigger scale than a single planet in this book. Also, the magic system is getting really interesting.
— Mar 18, 2026 11:23AM
Like flag
Amanda’s Previous Updates
Amanda Smith
is 75% done
Yes! Yes yes yes, this is what I've been wanting this whole damn book!
— 21 hours, 9 min ago
Amanda Smith
is 61% done
What. WHAT?!? Are you telling me that the bullshit second person POV, 'You do this, you do that,' was there so that we could have a sudden first personal reveal?????!??? I am infuriated and impressed. How dare you.
— 23 hours, 52 min ago
Amanda Smith
is 50% done
Wait, there's more than one male Lyctor? I can't tell these characters apart, I assumed it was one dude.
— Mar 25, 2026 11:58AM
Amanda Smith
is 38% done
Annabel Lee? That's an Edgar Allan Poe poem... Is this supposed to be our world?
— Mar 24, 2026 01:24PM
Amanda Smith
is 24% done
This Nonius character is driving me nuts. First, it's who Nonius is replacing. Second, the narrator chose a heavily burdened voice for Nonius, that sounds like a dying octogenarian. It's a burden to hear, I can't stand it. Not to mention the character says he's 35 years old, so it makes no sense.
— Mar 24, 2026 06:31AM
Amanda Smith
is 20% done
Harrowhark's memories of the last book are wrong. Did the Emperor mess with her mind? Or did Harrowhark?
— Mar 19, 2026 09:24AM
Amanda Smith
is 16% done
(2/2) and the Lyctors stop the beasts? If yes, he's selfish for living forever. They say power corrupts. Jury's still out.
— Mar 18, 2026 11:18AM
Amanda Smith
is 15% done
(1/2) I'm trying to decide if I like or trust the Emperor. He's written as a humble everyman turned God Emperor — worn out furniture, genuine concern for Harrow, more teacher than ruler. I like him. But should I? He's sending Harrow into a forever war, and it turns out his own resurrection and the Lyctors' sacrifices are what created the beasts they're fighting against. So the question becomes: would killing himself
— Mar 18, 2026 11:18AM

