Em’s Reviews > The Complete Sherlock Holmes: Volume I > Status Update
Em
is on page 97 of 709
Finished A Study in Scarlet and have counted it in the Penguin Classics Edition. It was 5/5 stars for me, intriguing for beginning to end. Highly enjoyed this story!
— Mar 24, 2026 08:56PM
Like flag
Em’s Previous Updates
Em
is on page 186 of 709
Just finished the Sign of Four.. I think this one didn’t hit the mark like ASIS because we knew the motive of why they murdered the people. In ASIS, it led up to it and then revealed. In ASOF, he already revealed the motive. I prefer having the motive revealed at the end I suppose.
— Mar 26, 2026 11:47AM
Em
is on page 66 of 709
18-66 3.23.26 The book is going so swell! The back and forth conversations between Holmes, the detectives, and Watson are very entertaining. I like the scene where Holmes is going along with the detectives and then he pulls out his own conclusion which is just a big "you're wrong" slap in the face. The Great Plains story pivot is also hitting the right spots for me. LOVE.
— Mar 23, 2026 08:40PM
