Brad’s Reviews > ...And Forgive Them Their Debts > Status Update

The prophets of Israel and Judah were well-connected men of influence, as were the Greek and Roman reformers and the Stoics who later influenced the Gracchi and other disaffected aristocrats in Rome. Although these reformers spoke on behalf of the poor against wealthy predators, they did not arise out of the poor classes.

Hammurabi heard many cases, or at least appeals of judgments, directly...However, access to the ruler would have been limited by the need to go through local officials or assemblies, whose ranks often included the abusive parties.

The letter of the law from the political center is all too easily corrupted in translation by go-betweens. On its own it's eventually an insufficient check.

Essential assets such as oxen could not be taken as pledges, because they were necessary means of production to produce crops, as well as to enable the debtor to pay taxes or work his way out of debt. Creditors who distrained such assets were fined one-third of a mina of silver, the same amount as for killing a man.

For much of this book, I'm left pondering anachronistic implications...

"‘One finds mention, here and there, of ‘peasant revolts,’ Jean Bottéro writes, ‘but these appear to have been provoked by terrible catastrophes such as famine, and are directed against an individual such as a king, not against an institution. In reality, the old inhabitants of Mesopotamia appear to have been devoid of any revolutionary spirit,’ as there was no idea of an alternative way to organize society."

The Sumerian interest rate on commercial loans, denominated in silver, was "set by ease of calculation rather than reflecting profit rates or productivity, and remained remarkably stable century after century.”

"...A similar grounding of the interest rate in the prevailing arithmetical system of weights and measures is found in subsequent regions for their local fractional system."

Even in the case of fines…the intention seems not to have been to impose such permanent distress on offenders as would deprive the social body of the wrongdoer's ability to meet his normal commitments.

Hudson ties the shifting of legal authority to creditors lacking such high-minded, longue durée concerns with civilizational decline. See: financialized debt in modern America.

"The relevance of studying antiquity's financial destiny is to see how the initial safety valves it enacted were dismantled by creditor oligarchies that imposed debt-ridden austerity as credit and markets became increasingly privatized."

"During times of a powerful state, i.e. Ur III, the state attempted to monopolize all propertyabd establishall production by state command; when the state was weak, i.e. Kassite Babylonia, property and production fell into the hands of private families and individuals."