Sarah Gabriel’s Reviews > In the House of Tom Bombadil > Status Update

I am NOT a fan of Wiley mentioning what Tolkien himself said Tom represents, and then debunking it and saying basically, "that's not it." The correct response is, "hmm, let's ask what he was implying when he said that and what he wanted us to think about." The way this section is written is extremely arrogant and disrespectful to authors.