Melanie’s Reviews > Shield of Sparrows > Status Update
Melanie
is 47% done
When does this get good?? The rating is amazing but so far I’ve read this exact story many many times before
— Jul 05, 2026 05:05PM
Like flag
Comments Showing 1-2 of 2 (2 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Kimberly
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Jul 06, 2026 11:37AM
The end of the middle so like 80% when all the reveals happen and by “get good” I mean just remain okay. It’s good if I never read another Romantasy but forgettable amongst the rest. You have to really relate with the characters or the world or the love interest to choose this book over the rest. It’s not bad but it’s not a stand out to me. No w that I’ve read a million Romantasy I’m looking for unique characters or unique journey or unique struggles. This is not that. I don’t even remember if I read the second one to see the end of the cliff hanger honestly I don’t remember the cliff hanger but I know there is one because there has to be. - in fact imma make this response my actual review dude
reply
|
flag
Hahaha! I love your response. And I agree! I have read so many Romantasy now that I really need something to stick out to me to differentiate it from the rest- whether it’s the love interest or world building or something. And the world building so far on this one isn’t different enough to do it for me. Same with the love interest

