Noora’s Reviews > Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: Parts One and Two > Status Update
Noora
is starting
I'm sure this is visually stunning and a great experience as a performance, but as a book this is terrible: the plot stinks, the characters are awkwardly bad and OOC, and the level of writing overall is subpar. as HP canon goes, this is unforgivable. this is cringeworthy bad fanfic levels of awful.
— Apr 27, 2017 01:01PM
Like flag
Noora’s Previous Updates
Noora
is starting
a book shouldn't be one massive "WTAF did I just read?!" !!!
— Oct 31, 2016 05:57PM
Noora
is starting
I truly didn't think it was possible to portray Harry as such an arse - and that's saying something. he may be a git several times in the septology but at least he was also our Harry, our beloved little friend. this play just... mangles everyone up and I hate that. don't do this to my childhood friends!
— Oct 31, 2016 05:38PM
Noora
is starting
honestly, who OK'd this load of shite? why was JKR so cool with Jack Thorne making a mockery out of all her years' beloved labour? this book makes me want to cry; I'm NOT cool with this mangling. I'm sure the play LOOKS stunning but even that doesn't take away from the awful characterisation and horrendous dialogue.
— Oct 29, 2016 04:10PM
Noora
is starting
is JKR okay? someone should check on her. agreeing to have her name attached to this crap is surely a desperate cry for help. I can't read more than three pages at a time because it's so bad. SO. BAD. and not even in a funny way.
— Oct 29, 2016 08:03AM
