Andrea Weil’s Reviews > A Fine and Private Place > Status Update
Andrea Weil
is on page 45 of 299
Being 44, the age Rebeck thinks Mrs Klepper to be, I realise that this might be the one thing that gives away, that Beagle was 19 (!) and unexperienced, when he wrote this thing. I love Gertrud as a character, but she sounds 30 years older than she is.
— 15 hours, 53 min ago
Like flag
Andrea’s Previous Updates
Andrea Weil
is on page 24 of 299
Not sure if Beagle intended Michael to be as dislikable as he is, but I'm sure he was meant to be flawed. I don't mind either as long as I get where they are coming from and there is growth. First one check, second one we'll see. And there are Rebeck and the Raven which I like very much.
— Jul 12, 2026 01:41PM