Mariannj’s Reviews > For All The Right Reasons > Status Update
Mariannj
is finished
I love the heroine except for her stupid pining after a man who's obviously in love with her sister.
After seeing them being intimate, she decides his kindness was just him being kind and treating her like a sister, so she finally resolves to stop pining after him. Then literally the next page, she's pining again. 😭😂 Have some self-respect, girl!
— Aug 03, 2026 12:01AM
After seeing them being intimate, she decides his kindness was just him being kind and treating her like a sister, so she finally resolves to stop pining after him. Then literally the next page, she's pining again. 😭😂 Have some self-respect, girl!
Like flag
Mariannj’s Previous Updates
Mariannj
is finished
At this point, the heroine just comes across as obsessed and completely lacking in self-awareness. I honestly want to smack some sense into her. I can't believe I'm still torturing myself by continuing this book. I you also get stupid like the heroine as you read this book. 😂
— Aug 03, 2026 01:37AM
Mariannj
is finished
“It didn't bother her that he had been in love with Karin. She had always known she was better suited to Alex than Karin was.”
The heroine must be delusional. How can she confidently declare that she's better suited to the hero when he's been in love with her sister for years? She doesn't get to dictate who's the better match. That’s for the hero to decide, not her. 😭
— Aug 03, 2026 01:35AM
The heroine must be delusional. How can she confidently declare that she's better suited to the hero when he's been in love with her sister for years? She doesn't get to dictate who's the better match. That’s for the hero to decide, not her. 😭
Mariannj
is finished
For a heroine who's supposed to be smart, she isn't so smart after all. I just hate it when a character pines for someone who doesn't like them—especially for years. Imagine that. What's there to pine after if he's in love with your sister?
And it’s as if the man is worth pining for anyway. The brother is so much better. The better man.
— Aug 03, 2026 12:02AM
And it’s as if the man is worth pining for anyway. The brother is so much better. The better man.
Mariannj
is finished
I just don't understand why the heroine’s clinging to someone whose heart seems to be elsewhere. To me, continuing to pine after a man who clearly prefers your sister doesn't come across as romantic, it comes across as a lack of self-respect. I hope the story gives the heroine some growth because, at this point, it's becoming frustrating to read.
— Aug 02, 2026 11:10PM
Mariannj
is finished
I'm on page 132 of *For All the Right Reasons*, and I'm struggling to understand the heroine. She's still pining after a man who quite obviously has feelings for her sister. Meanwhile, his brother has openly admitted that he likes her and has been consistently kind and attentive toward her.
— Aug 02, 2026 11:09PM

