Indigo Starcroft’s Reviews > This Book Made Me Think of You > Status Update
Indigo Starcroft
is on page 328 of 407
i am so over this fucking book. Alfie did nothing wrong. obviously somebody that was looking to be more than friends does that sorta thing. i hate tilly as a character. she has so much money she can live in london and travel without having a job. for all we know she could buy the building for him and she does a...social media post? and all the melodrama with Harper. The dialogue was bland before now its just cringe.
— Sep 14, 2026 08:40AM
Like flag
Indigo’s Previous Updates
Indigo Starcroft
is on page 296 of 407
Oh my god. Finally we are getting to what I think was the point. But with all this side tracking with these pointless trips that bring no substance...and roughly 100 pages to go? This is a bad book and I will be donating it first chance I get.
— Sep 10, 2026 07:09AM
Indigo Starcroft
is on page 260 of 407
Its like reading the blandest account. This was supposed to be about reading books, but instead the end of a 'plot point' there is something shoe horned in from a book. In fact, the book is more about Tilly's travels and quickly avoiding any bad feelings rather than actually be introspective. I know this is supposed to be light and fun, but the level of unawareness seeps into the prose to the point of disbelief.
— Sep 09, 2026 10:33AM
Indigo Starcroft
is on page 236 of 407
Put it down for a minute. Still kinda hate it. Still reads stiff even though tilly is having an emotional time with mom in law. The shit with Harper is wild, making someone a dating profile after their husband dying of cancer. Not unbelievable, but unbelievable if that makes sense
— Sep 07, 2026 02:20PM
Indigo Starcroft
is on page 214 of 407
Oh of course Sarah. J maas is name dropped.
— Aug 30, 2026 07:41AM
Indigo Starcroft
is on page 177 of 407
I am getting annoyed at this pattern where we learn things about Joe but its only in isolation for the month. Like June we learn they ran together? Why not have sprinkled that seed in January? People starting to jog for their new years resolution. It feels like everything is isolated to that month and each new book is a new thing that wont be discussed (much if at all) again.
— Aug 29, 2026 10:21AM
Indigo Starcroft
is on page 142 of 407
The paris trip after the Bali trip feels so milk toast. And again, I dont get to have Billy's emotional reactions to going through all the books she gets to read. Im glad that there is another plot line developing because so much of this is boring. Not even sweet and fantastical, its worse than hallmark
— Aug 28, 2026 06:00PM
Indigo Starcroft
is on page 116 of 407
She never allows for me to feel things other than elation with tilly. Like, when she is in Bali and she is having this emotional crescendo where she uploads herself in tears, its blown by. It felt so melodramatic. I feel the sickly sweetness and the joy and wonder. But never any of the negative. I want to feel this grief with this character but the author never gives any room
— Aug 27, 2026 10:10AM
Indigo Starcroft
is on page 82 of 407
I swear most of this book could have been cut and others aren't long enough. Like i would have liked to know Tilly's emotional journey throughout reading Matilda, but the small talk and bits of work? Sure, work is hard, but so much feels like it could have been cut.
— Aug 26, 2026 08:14AM
Indigo Starcroft
is on page 32 of 407
and this is why we don't pick up random book club books unless we know we are going to read them on time. I picked this up in February. And to be honest, getting this far I have no idea why I would continue unless it was for a book club.
— Aug 25, 2026 02:50PM