Amanda Smith’s Reviews > Rhythm of War > Status Update
Like flag
Amanda’s Previous Updates
Amanda Smith
is 70% done
King Taravangian might be my favorite character. His actions are so villainous but his intentions are pure. He truly wants to save humanity, and will make the horrific sacrifices necessary. He's a foil to Dalinar, who is also determined to save humanity, but with 'honor'. My heart goes out to dumb Taravangian who is full of empathy, but trapped by his own crimes and actions.
— Nov 02, 2026 01:20AM
Amanda Smith
is 40% done
The manic pixie dream girl is learning to be depressed.
— Oct 31, 2026 10:30AM
Amanda Smith
is 28% done
Also it seems Kaladin might have a potential love interest on the other side... Though now that he's focusing on being a surgeon I'm not sure how they're going to see each other again.
We're getting a lot more Navani than Dalinar or Jasnah, which kind of bums me out, but is also intriguing. She's building important machines and getting death threats for it. I don't think Sanderson can write a boring character!
— Oct 29, 2026 01:17PM
We're getting a lot more Navani than Dalinar or Jasnah, which kind of bums me out, but is also intriguing. She's building important machines and getting death threats for it. I don't think Sanderson can write a boring character!
Amanda Smith
is 28% done
Adolin is turning into quite the dandy. Good for him. He's a heterosexual manly man who loves clothes and fashion, and we need more of that.
And for all that I love his father too, Dalinar is a strict military man, who does not approve of frivolous or unprofessional dress. Adolin needs to break away from his father's control. This is good for him.
— Oct 29, 2026 01:12PM
And for all that I love his father too, Dalinar is a strict military man, who does not approve of frivolous or unprofessional dress. Adolin needs to break away from his father's control. This is good for him.
Amanda Smith
is 7% done
(3/3) -share his own. While she hasn't shared everything yet you can tell that Adolin will understand her horrible secrets when/if she eventually tells him, and will also understand if she keeps them. He has the openness and empathy to do that. Whereas Kaladin would fucking explod. I truly couldn't see him and Shallan together. Meanwhile Shallan and Adolin seem like a perfect match, even when one half is broken.
— Oct 27, 2026 07:13PM
Amanda Smith
is 7% done
(2/3) Meanwhile Adolin has been vulnerable with Shallan. When he eventually did something he couldn't share, it tortured him. When he finally did confess, Shallan was the first person he told.
Meanwhile Shallan, for all that she's also charismatic and fun and seemingly open like Adolin, has a million secrets, many very painful. She hasn't shared all of them, but her sharing one is what made Adolin break down and-
— Oct 27, 2026 07:09PM
Meanwhile Shallan, for all that she's also charismatic and fun and seemingly open like Adolin, has a million secrets, many very painful. She hasn't shared all of them, but her sharing one is what made Adolin break down and-
Amanda Smith
is 7% done
Thank god the Shallan/Kaladin nonsense is over. I've liked Shallan and Adolin since it started; Adolin is both heroic and charming, and he has a tenderness to him that Kaladin doesn't.
Kaladin has become a real jerk since the first book, understandably, and while I still like him as a protag, he had zero vulnerability with Shallan, even during the scenes when we saw his and Shallan's attraction to each other.
— Oct 27, 2026 07:04PM
Kaladin has become a real jerk since the first book, understandably, and while I still like him as a protag, he had zero vulnerability with Shallan, even during the scenes when we saw his and Shallan's attraction to each other.
Amanda Smith
is starting
(3/3) Bitch, she can't spend her time being an engineer because she's managing YOUR kingdom, and doing YOUR job! 💢
— Oct 27, 2026 02:08PM

