Andre’s Reviews > Roggenwolf und Roggenhund im germanischen Brauchtum > Status Update
Like flag
Andre’s Previous Updates
Andre
is finished
is he criticizing Jacob Grimm for seeing pagan gods everywhere? Didn't he basically do the same? He connected the rye wolf to Fenrir and now he dismisses the claim that the rye wolf is Odin's/Wodan's wolves? And why, now at the end of the book, does he claim the rye wolf is connected to the dogs of the wild hunt?
— Nov 13, 2026 12:31AM
Andre
is finished
Storm beings are often portrayed as healing gods because the storm clears the air? Since when? I would like some evidence please, because I can only think of the opposite.
— Nov 13, 2026 12:21AM
Andre
is finished
what?! Now he claims he doesn't want to connect the rye wolf with Fenrir and his family? That was exactly what he did before!!!!!!
— Nov 13, 2026 12:18AM
Andre
is finished
The rye wolf as a part of the germanic giant tales? Based on what? The rye wolf is not a giant. Does he confuse Jotun with giant? Even that doesn't work as jotun are primarily anti-gods, but that he said himself that the rye wolf is a being that is both a blessing to the fields/humans and a danger.
— Nov 13, 2026 12:16AM
Andre
is finished
And even more claims of connections to Fenrir, even a claim that Fenrir is somehow a storm wolf.
— Nov 13, 2026 12:14AM
Andre
is finished
who wouldn't think of Fenrir when seeing the bound rye wolf? Me!!! That he even draws the connection show his bias towards a connection to norse mythology. Because there is no evidence of the Fenris wolf outside of skandinavia.
— Nov 13, 2026 12:13AM
Andre
is finished
I was wondering when he would come with the old germanic myths claim. When this was written, the claim of ancient germanic sources was all vogue.
— Nov 13, 2026 12:09AM
Andre
is finished
He claims that the rye wolf can shift between wolf and human, but he provides no evidence, not even an example as to where this was believed.
— Nov 13, 2026 12:07AM
Andre
is finished
So there are humanlike grain spirits as well, this here is a woman whom the author states to be the mothers of the wolves, but why? He doesn't say.
— Nov 13, 2026 12:03AM
Andre
is finished
So in one place in Thurgau, Switzerland, this spirit is a lion. I wonder how that came to be. Usually it is an animal native to the region.
— Nov 12, 2026 11:58PM

