Joseph’s Reviews > The Book of Mormon: Another Testament of Jesus Christ > Status Update
Joseph
is on page 399 of 531
At some point Smith got sick of making up new names.
— 15 hours, 30 min ago
Like flag
Joseph’s Previous Updates
Joseph
is on page 389 of 531
"For surely it is the earth that moveth and not the sun."
Smith probably intended this to prove that his book is even better than the Bible, but it just makes it more obvious that it's a modern invention. I don't care much if the Bible idiomatically says that "the sun stood still," but I find it suspicious that God only put a scientific explanation in the book that gets "revealed" after Copernicus.
— Nov 16, 2026 01:37PM
Smith probably intended this to prove that his book is even better than the Bible, but it just makes it more obvious that it's a modern invention. I don't care much if the Bible idiomatically says that "the sun stood still," but I find it suspicious that God only put a scientific explanation in the book that gets "revealed" after Copernicus.
Joseph
is on page 384 of 531
"Now behold, notwithstanding that great miracle which Nephi had done in telling them concerning the death of the chief judge, they did harden their hearts and did not hearken unto the words of the Lord."
This comes one page after that same miracle had everyone deciding that he WAS a prophet, and some even declaring him to be a god.
— Nov 15, 2026 09:27AM
This comes one page after that same miracle had everyone deciding that he WAS a prophet, and some even declaring him to be a god.
Joseph
is on page 380 of 531
"And now, seeing ye know these things and cannot deny them except ye shall lie, therefore in this ye have sinned, for ye have rejected all these things, notwithstanding so many evidences which ye have received."
The "evidence" here is a list of prophets, 3/4 of whom were made up for this book.
— Nov 13, 2026 01:22PM
The "evidence" here is a list of prophets, 3/4 of whom were made up for this book.
Joseph
is on page 378 of 531
"And now we know that this is impossible, for behold, we are powerful, and our cities. great, therefore our enemies can have no power over us."
Your capital city has been conquered twice in this book, dudes.
— Nov 13, 2026 01:14PM
Your capital city has been conquered twice in this book, dudes.
Joseph
is on page 378 of 531
"Yea, many things did Nephi speak which cannot be written."
Why not? Does God's revelation have a word limit? And if so, shouldn't you list the things that he said that are "plot significant" out the vaguer, repetitive bits?
— Nov 13, 2026 01:13PM
Why not? Does God's revelation have a word limit? And if so, shouldn't you list the things that he said that are "plot significant" out the vaguer, repetitive bits?
Joseph
is on page 366 of 531
Also, we keep hearing about these "dissentions" and "contentions" that aren't even explained a lot of the time. WHAT are the Nephites arguing about so much that some of them are trying to convince their greatest enemies to come and kill everyone? Surely this is relevant to what is supposed to be a historical account?
— Nov 11, 2026 02:17PM
Joseph
is on page 366 of 531
"Lamanites again invade land of Zarahemla"—Yes, again, because all of Smith's plot points are just variations on a theme.
The Book of Judges was repetitive, but at least it had a bunch of different nations to fight, and some cool miracles.
— Nov 11, 2026 02:03PM
The Book of Judges was repetitive, but at least it had a bunch of different nations to fight, and some cool miracles.
Joseph
is on page 360 of 531
"There began to be a serious contention concerning who should have the judgment-seat among his brethren, who were the sons of Pahoran."
"Pacumeni was appointed, according to the voice of the people[...]in the stead of his brother Pahoran; and it was according to his right."
So for all the railing against monarchy, we have a system where rulership still passes via primogeniture, but with a symbolic election first?
— Nov 09, 2026 10:04PM
"Pacumeni was appointed, according to the voice of the people[...]in the stead of his brother Pahoran; and it was according to his right."
So for all the railing against monarchy, we have a system where rulership still passes via primogeniture, but with a symbolic election first?
Joseph
is on page 355 of 531
"hey caused them to enter into a covenant that they would no more take up their weapons of war against the Nephites. And when they had entered into this covenant they sent them to dwell with the people of Ammon."
The people of Ammon don't count as Nephites, do they? I feel like you're setting yourself up for a problem here.
— Nov 08, 2026 07:01PM
The people of Ammon don't count as Nephites, do they? I feel like you're setting yourself up for a problem here.
Joseph
is on page 354 of 531
"Yea, and whosoever was found denying their freedom was speedily executed according to the law[...]having inflicted death upon all those who were not true to the cause of freedom."
I question this "cause of freedom," which was mandated by a king and which people will be executed for questioning.
— Nov 08, 2026 06:55PM
I question this "cause of freedom," which was mandated by a king and which people will be executed for questioning.

