Mary’s Reviews > The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Riddle of Ages > Status Update
Mary
is on page 235 of 391
I finally realized what this reminds me of: Sherlock Holmes at Reichenbach falls. The book where Conan Doyle killed off Sherlock Holmes because he was tired of writing about him. But that doesn’t really make sense because Stewart had already essentially quit writing books about these kids. He could have just left it as It was.
— Oct 07, 2019 08:28AM
Like flag
Mary’s Previous Updates
Mary
is on page 229 of 391
The action moves at a snail’s pace.
I can’t believe that after waiting YEARS for an installment to this series, the book is a painful disintegration of the society.
— Oct 06, 2019 10:01PM
I can’t believe that after waiting YEARS for an installment to this series, the book is a painful disintegration of the society.
Mary
is on page 141 of 391
I’m really hoping that the title riddle of the ages does not refer to the fact that we don’t know how old these kids are because that would be really irritating.
— Oct 06, 2019 08:40PM
Mary
is on page 141 of 391
This book makes me feel sad and slightly ill. It captures that moment when kids lose their confidence and exuberance and belief in themselves and in life and start doubting themselves. Why on earth would you write a book about that?
— Oct 06, 2019 07:04PM
Mary
is on page 100 of 391
“She reminded her self that it was OK to have secrets sometimes. After all, isn’t every unspoken thought a secret?”
— Oct 06, 2019 04:52PM
Mary
is on page 89 of 391
I’m still waiting to enjoy this book. It’s very frustrating to read this because it still hasn’t said how old the kids are except that Constance is not a teenager or a tween ager. I think she was six last time so perhaps she’s somewhere between six and 11. And the rest of the kids are odd. They used to have such distinct personalities and now they don’t have any personality at all.
— Oct 06, 2019 04:40PM
Mary
is on page 46 of 391
We pick up “years later” than the previous book with no mention of how old the kids are now. It’s very disorienting.
I wouldn’t recommend reading this book without first reading previous books in the series.
— Oct 06, 2019 01:40PM
I wouldn’t recommend reading this book without first reading previous books in the series.

