[Name Redacted]’s Reviews > A Wind in Cairo > Status Update

[Name Redacted]
[Name Redacted] is on page 29 of 262
Feb 03, 2015 03:29PM
A Wind in Cairo

flag

[Name Redacted]’s Previous Updates

[Name Redacted]
[Name Redacted] is finished
Oh. Ok. SURE. It makes perfect sense thst the rapist should get the girl. Because he's really good-looking. Even though she didn't know him till the last 30 pages, and had two far better men openly courting her AND respecting her. Ugh. In the last 75 pages this book went from 5-star to 3-star. And it only merits that because the prose is gorgeous. >:(
Feb 05, 2015 08:36AM
A Wind in Cairo


[Name Redacted]
[Name Redacted] is on page 206 of 262
Yep. Tarr can try to paint it however she likes, but it's all just Stockholm Syndrome as a means of whitewashing the fact that her family was slaughtered by Islamic soldiers and she was made into a literal sex slave by them. But never fear! Being an Islamic sex slave is better than being a free, high-born European Christian. I'm...not sure i can finish this. Blergh.
Feb 05, 2015 06:14AM
A Wind in Cairo


[Name Redacted]
[Name Redacted] is on page 189 of 262
Ugh, i had forgotten how much Tarr romanticizes Islam. In that way that only Westerners with no real experience or understanding can...
Feb 05, 2015 05:49AM
A Wind in Cairo


[Name Redacted]
[Name Redacted] is on page 189 of 262
So...to justify making the protagonists Muslims, she decided to make the Christians bestial mustache-twirling evil-doers? And somehow the fact that the Frankish girl was FIRST raped by Muslims is okay, but the Frankish men raping her (improbably) is beyond the pale? And then she chooses to side with the Muslims? I'm sorry, it only makes the MALES of all peoples seem bad AND sound like she has Stockholm Syndrome.
Feb 05, 2015 05:47AM
A Wind in Cairo


[Name Redacted]
[Name Redacted] is on page 177 of 262
Feb 05, 2015 04:07AM
A Wind in Cairo


[Name Redacted]
[Name Redacted] is on page 157 of 262
Feb 05, 2015 12:50AM
A Wind in Cairo


[Name Redacted]
[Name Redacted] is on page 115 of 262
Feb 04, 2015 05:46PM
A Wind in Cairo


[Name Redacted]
[Name Redacted] is on page 67 of 262
Feb 03, 2015 10:23PM
A Wind in Cairo


[Name Redacted]
[Name Redacted] is on page 53 of 262
Feb 03, 2015 05:27PM
A Wind in Cairo


No comments have been added yet.