HRose/Abalieno’s Reviews > The First Binding: A Silk Road epic fantasy full of magic and mystery > Status Update
HRose/Abalieno
is on page 80 of 817
...Not sure what to make of it.
Style is overstated and emphatic.
Two unique persons meet by chance in a inn, proceed to take a stroll under the rain and into a different inn. Sit at a table to eat, still drenched and making no attempt at drying. Then get back to the first inn, go to the roof to sit under the rain a while longer.
No shit given about consistency, author simply thought it poetic and emotional.
— Jun 20, 2024 12:44PM
Style is overstated and emphatic.
Two unique persons meet by chance in a inn, proceed to take a stroll under the rain and into a different inn. Sit at a table to eat, still drenched and making no attempt at drying. Then get back to the first inn, go to the roof to sit under the rain a while longer.
No shit given about consistency, author simply thought it poetic and emotional.
Like flag
HRose/Abalieno’s Previous Updates
HRose/Abalieno
is on page 105 of 817
...project for an alternate timeline, to do a joint review of this and sequel. While reading Rothfuss in parallel.
Naive accusations of plagiarism are part of the appeal.
Funny that Virdi already wrote more words than Rothfuss. The real intent is to "re-dress" indian myths, likely being the LARGEST body of work known to humanity.
Chapter at page 97 is titled BRAHM, it's precisely what it sounds like.
— Aug 14, 2025 08:37PM
Naive accusations of plagiarism are part of the appeal.
Funny that Virdi already wrote more words than Rothfuss. The real intent is to "re-dress" indian myths, likely being the LARGEST body of work known to humanity.
Chapter at page 97 is titled BRAHM, it's precisely what it sounds like.
HRose/Abalieno
is on page 14 of 817
I picked up this one BECAUSE of all the inflammatory, negative reviews I've read.
Quite curious to read alongside Ruocchio, as both are accused of plagiarizing The Name of The Wind. Here in a much more brazen way.
Fact is, this is almost a taunt. I appreciate that type of challenge and the careless risk of it. First chapter felt a bit wonky. I reread it three times, but I feel adjusted now. We shall see...
— Jun 09, 2024 03:23AM
Quite curious to read alongside Ruocchio, as both are accused of plagiarizing The Name of The Wind. Here in a much more brazen way.
Fact is, this is almost a taunt. I appreciate that type of challenge and the careless risk of it. First chapter felt a bit wonky. I reread it three times, but I feel adjusted now. We shall see...
