Abby Crane’s Reviews > A Good Girl's Guide to Murder > Status Update
Abby Crane
is on page 298 of 433
⚠️Spoilers and Trigger Warning⚠️ Read at your own risk!
This book just made me mad. I can't believe they actually had the nerve to kill a dog in this book. I get that Barney's death is probably what's going to drive Pip to find Sal and Andie's killer. But I'm heartbroken. Also, how stupid of the killer to tell Pip they'll give her her dog back if she destroys evidence and then kill the dog anyway.
— Jan 23, 2025 11:27PM
This book just made me mad. I can't believe they actually had the nerve to kill a dog in this book. I get that Barney's death is probably what's going to drive Pip to find Sal and Andie's killer. But I'm heartbroken. Also, how stupid of the killer to tell Pip they'll give her her dog back if she destroys evidence and then kill the dog anyway.
1 like · Like flag
Abby’s Previous Updates
Abby Crane
is on page 335 of 433
⚠️Spoilers!⚠️
Now...why did we have a "liar revealed" scene only to automatically undo the emotional impact of the scene in the very next chapter? It makes Ravi look stupid and insensitive. Also, why would Pip not just be honest with Ravi? It's not like the killer would know she told him. Chapters 36 and 37 were pretty bad, honestly. Took me out of the book a bit.
— Jan 27, 2025 08:19PM
Now...why did we have a "liar revealed" scene only to automatically undo the emotional impact of the scene in the very next chapter? It makes Ravi look stupid and insensitive. Also, why would Pip not just be honest with Ravi? It's not like the killer would know she told him. Chapters 36 and 37 were pretty bad, honestly. Took me out of the book a bit.
