Ashley’s Reviews > If She Were Dead > Status Update
Ashley
is on page 267 of 320
"She was like a doll that wets or cries 'Mama': the disposable Amelie. You can brush her hair, take off her little outfits, twist her limbs this way and that, and then, if you like, you can just toss her away. Bye-bye, Disposable Amelie. Because there's always a bright new toy waiting on the shelf." This is the first decent analogy I've read throughout the book even though it had me singing Barbie Girl in my head.
— Dec 26, 2025 02:52PM
Like flag
Ashley’s Previous Updates
Ashley
is on page 188 of 320
"[...] And she didn't know why she said it, why there was something problematic in taking Ben's son from point A to point B, why he was any different than his sister. Somewhere in the crevices of the equation, in the esoteric angles of its logic, lay some further problem, something unclear that might get in the way, throw off the equation, skew the result." See what I mean? The author constantly does this!!!!
— Dec 26, 2025 09:10AM
Ashley
is on page 185 of 320
“She stopped this line of thinking immediately, for by the end of the hour she would have come to despise the ugly witless gnome that her lover had become in her estimation.” Like this book is giving me tonal whiplash because why is it modern day and then turns medieval like this???
— Dec 21, 2025 10:57AM
Ashley
is on page 185 of 320
Part of me does feel like maybe her daughter’s new man is also Ben but part of me just feels like maybe that’s me hoping because that would be interesting and the book is so fucking boring lol
— Dec 21, 2025 10:54AM
Ashley
is on page 185 of 320
I think the author tried overly hard to make this book seem well-written by overdoing similes and metaphors throughout and trying to articulate their thinking because it’s 3rd person POV and it just comes out as wordy and not memorable because it’s just too much if that makes sense. Like I’m on chapter 37 and there’s nothing notable that has happened or been described.
— Dec 21, 2025 10:53AM
Ashley
is on page 93 of 320
"Why don't you go run to your woman, why don't you go and let her have the pleasure of your middle aged body. One of these days and it's a guarantee, Richard, one of these days you'll rise from bed and she'll crack open her big vacant eyes&she'll look at you and say 'Omg what have I done, why am I living w/this saggy lump of human waste?' & then you'll try to come back&I won't be alone'
READ HIM FOR FILTH LMAOOOOO
— Nov 20, 2025 04:27AM
READ HIM FOR FILTH LMAOOOOO
Ashley
is on page 80 of 320
All the analogies & the smilies every other sentence are so distracting from the plot
— Nov 14, 2025 05:48PM
Ashley
is on page 59 of 320
Weird that I’m 59 pages in and this is the second that it was mentioned Amelie has never had a problem w weight? Like ok? Is her being thin and snatched have some premise to the plot orrrrr?
— Nov 08, 2025 01:46PM
Ashley
is on page 52 of 320
Amelie is me af when my man and I get into it, now I gotta fix it before I enjoy anything again.
— Nov 07, 2025 06:23PM
Ashley
is on page 38 of 320
Why do I have a feeling that Nina is following in her mom’s footsteps & playing side chick to her professor? 👀
— Nov 06, 2025 10:33PM
Ashley
is on page 18 of 320
“It was strange how nothing was ever truly final. People might return, change their minds, take back their words.”
— Nov 06, 2025 06:13PM

