Phil’s Reviews > The Sea Captain's Wife > Status Update
Phil
is on page 35 of 288
this is getting decent, but I would've appreciated some sources... had to do my own research to check some things smh
— Mar 10, 2026 06:27PM
Like flag
Phil’s Previous Updates
Phil
is on page 182 of 288
this book would've been more interesting and enjoyable to read if it was pure fiction, then I could excuse the sloppy research, basic mistakes, and the early 2000s fanfiction-style of romance writing
— Mar 14, 2026 02:24AM
Phil
is on page 115 of 288
This books keeps randomly jumping from topic to topic so much that it's extremely hard to stay interested in reading it ngl
— Mar 13, 2026 02:53AM
Phil
is on page 101 of 288
This book is such bullshit tbh, it still can't decide if it's a romance historical fiction, a sailing almanach, or some sort of biography. To describe in excruciating detail the Beaufort scale and not even ONCE mention it's called the Beaufort scale?! And then jump into some random facts about a coastline? Who the fuck edited this shit. Still not over the typo in Eldridge's name, this shit ain't been fact checked.
— Mar 12, 2026 05:46PM
Phil
is 7% done
Very mixed feelings about this book so far, leaning towards "bad"
— Mar 10, 2026 01:40PM
