BrokenTune’s Reviews > Fatty O'Leary's Dinner Party > Status Update
BrokenTune
is on page 41 of 174
Book club read. This is pretty bad so far. Patronising, fat-phobibc, ... quite insulting to this reader's sense of what is and is not funny.
I read McCall-Smith before and didn't rate it, but I thought I'd try again for the sake of the book club read. It's going to be my last book by the author.
Thankfully, this is a very short read.
— Aug 16, 2026 01:18AM
I read McCall-Smith before and didn't rate it, but I thought I'd try again for the sake of the book club read. It's going to be my last book by the author.
Thankfully, this is a very short read.
Like flag
BrokenTune’s Previous Updates
BrokenTune
is on page 54 of 174
Wow. The book is also hitting ALL of the stereotypes. So, disappointing.
— Aug 16, 2026 01:29AM