Josiah’s Reviews > Eighth Grade Witch > Status Update

You and Zora Belladonna have the power to defeat Prudence Deadly, it seems. You get her in both of these endings. And with this one on page 119, I am finally done with Eighth Grade Witch.

Turned into a cockroach by Prudence Deadly, huh? It's not the weirdest ending in these pages.

I like this double-page drawing of the cats (good work, Gabhor Utomo), but once again the story just...stops. No resolution is even attempted.

It's astonishing how confusing this book is. Why wasn't a proper editor assigned to overhaul C.E. Simpson's narrative work?

Can we please get a coherent ending? I want to like this book, but it's trying hard to render that an impossibility.

Not only is every part of this story disjointed, but most of the endings leave off before any real resolution is brought. I hate to say this may be the worst Choose Your Own Nightmare in either iteration of the series, but...

Probably the book's most nightmarish ending, but the graphic horror can't make it into an actual ending. It offers zero closure to the storyline.

Will the police be able to help, or are they in on the paranormal corruption like most everyone else in Graves End, Brooklyn?

Can we avoid the evil librarian and all the other minions at this school by just using the Internet to research Astrid and her ilk?

This story is a hard to follow mess for the most part. I wonder if we can still find a way to counteract the junior coven of witches without Peter's direct help.