Spencer’s Reviews > Achtung Panzer!: The Development of Tank Warfare > Status Update

Spencer
Spencer is 63% done
"However there remained one obstacle – the fact that our military and political leadership lacked the nerve to free itself from the Versailles restrictions."

I wasn't there or a German General but, How would Germany have fared against the French and British with mock tanks and wooden guns, Heinz? While as unfair as they saw the treaty, wouldnt it be prudent to build up before breaching the treaty?
— Oct 29, 2026 08:26AM
Achtung Panzer!: The Development of Tank Warfare (W&N Military)

flag

Spencer’s Previous Updates

Spencer
Spencer is 52% done
"the army was in real danger of letting them (tanks) slip from its mind altogether, or at least under-valuing them to a greater or lesser extent."

What he actually misses hear is the advantages of being a late adopter of a technology. While lose on some technical knowledge and training early you miss all the sunk costs Inherent in new designs. You get to scan the field for the best designs. Germany did that.
— Oct 20, 2026 02:45PM
Achtung Panzer!: The Development of Tank Warfare (W&N Military)


Spencer
Spencer is 52% done
(Speaking on the Versailles Treaty)"it is unlikely that they had our best interests at heart when they came to determine the composition of our army."

Yea, no shit.
— Oct 20, 2026 02:41PM
Achtung Panzer!: The Development of Tank Warfare (W&N Military)


Spencer
Spencer is 48% done
"And yet again the cavalry showed themselves quite unfitted to appear on the modern battlefield"

This answers my previous question. He was clearly referencing what they force had with them at the time not that they should use cavalry going forward.
— Oct 18, 2026 09:03AM
Achtung Panzer!: The Development of Tank Warfare (W&N Military)


Spencer
Spencer is 41% done
"The intervention of horsed cavalry should have been considered only after the breakthrough had succeeded, when open country had been reached"

I wonder if at this point in his analysis if he was putting this in only to appease the Cavalry fudds, or if he actually thought there is still use for it?
— Oct 15, 2026 08:20AM
Achtung Panzer!: The Development of Tank Warfare (W&N Military)


Spencer
Spencer is 33% done
"if only Third Ypres had never happened! If only it were possible to bring back to life all the divisions which had been sacrificed in that stupendous grinding battle! Twenty-two million pounds had been expended on ammunition in that struggle – if only they had been devoted to tanks instead!"

Its hard to know of this is serious sentiment, or just salting an open wound of the British.
— Aug 06, 2026 10:40AM
Achtung Panzer!: The Development of Tank Warfare (W&N Military)


Spencer
Spencer is 29% done
"It is every bit as wrong to lay down a preparatory bombardment which reduces the terrain to a lunar landscape."

I wonder what the contemporary conceptualization of lunar landscapes were at this time. Clearly by this quote its not far off from reality, but its not like they had lunar probes taking pictures in the 30s.
— May 20, 2026 07:38PM
Achtung Panzer!: The Development of Tank Warfare (W&N Military)


Spencer
Spencer is 22% done
"The endurance of the British infantry had been severely tested in the process [Somme], and public opinion at home was shaken".

This entire part of the book is pure copium from a German Officer. Guderian spends this first part pointing out casualties the Allies took vs Germans. Then gives Verdun a paragraph. You guys lost, this is a book about Tanks, just put the the fries in the bag, sir.
— Dec 31, 2025 09:27AM
Achtung Panzer!: The Development of Tank Warfare (W&N Military)


Spencer
Spencer is 19% done
"Among other measures Captain Martel, R.E. (of later fame) was given the task of creating a training area at Elveden in Suffolk."

While reading this pre WW2 work on how potentially damaging it is to release simple information about top secret development projects. Because of a book released in Britain, Germany (and others) know the location and details of Britain's Tank project and whose involved.
— Nov 18, 2025 07:17AM
Achtung Panzer!: The Development of Tank Warfare (W&N Military)


No comments have been added yet.