We Were Liars by E. LockhartThe Silkworm by Robert Galbraith
Best Books of 2014
3,571 books — 6,301 voters
The Girl on the Train by Paula HawkinsAll the Bright Places by Jennifer NivenCareer of Evil by Robert GalbraithAfter You by Jojo Moyes
Best Books of 2015
3,105 books — 5,120 voters

The Widow by Fiona BartonThe Girl in the Ice by Robert BryndzaThe Couple Next Door by Shari LapenaRadio Silence by Alice OsemanTry Not to Breathe by Holly Seddon
Best Books of 2016
1,831 books — 2,784 voters
The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins ReidThe Roanoke Girls by Amy EngelLast Breath by Robert BryndzaThe Good Daughter by Karin SlaughterI Am, I Am, I Am by Maggie O'Farrell
Best Books of 2017
1,734 books — 3,081 voters

Then She Was Gone by Lisa JewellSadie by Courtney SummersHeartstopper by Alice OsemanMilkman by Anna BurnsStill Me by Jojo Moyes
Best Books of 2018
1,649 books — 2,956 voters
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder by Holly  JacksonThe Last Widow by Karin SlaughterDaisy Jones & The Six by Taylor Jenkins ReidHeartstopper by Alice OsemanThe Family Upstairs by Lisa Jewell
Best Books of 2019
1,389 books — 1,961 voters

Hamnet by Maggie O'FarrellTroubled Blood by Robert GalbraithThe Thursday Murder Club by Richard OsmanHeartstopper by Alice OsemanThe Midnight Library by Matt Haig
Best Books of 2020
1,564 books — 1,935 voters
Heartstopper by Alice OsemanThe Night She Disappeared by Lisa JewellThe Push by Ashley AudrainCrying in H Mart by Michelle ZaunerRock Paper Scissors by Alice Feeney
Best Books of 2021
1,431 books — 1,624 voters

Lessons in Chemistry by Bonnie GarmusTomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow by Gabrielle ZevinThe School for Good Mothers by Jessamine ChanHidden Pictures by Jason RekulakDelilah Green Doesn't Care by Ashley Herring Blake
Best Books of 2022
1,540 books — 1,854 voters
The Drowning Woman by Robyn Harding
Best Books of 2023
1,206 books — 1,840 voters

Local Girl Missing by Claire DouglasPlay Dead by Angela MarsonsAll I Ever Wanted by Lucy DillonLuckiest Girl Alive by Jessica KnollLost Girls by Angela Marsons
2017: What the Over-35s Are Reading
2,707 books — 203 voters

Sharp Objects by Gillian FlynnThe Silkworm by Robert GalbraithCareer of Evil by Robert GalbraithDark Places by Gillian FlynnWhat Alice Forgot by Liane Moriarty
2016: What the Over-35s Are Reading
2,499 books — 180 voters